RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2026 · 24 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2026 Chemistry question — Reactive intermediates and rearrangements

Arrange the following carbanions in the decreasing order of stability.

24th shift 1 52


Choose the correct answer from the options given below:

SOLUTION

Stability of a carbanion is governed mainly by three factors:
  • Delocalisation (resonance or aromaticity) that can spread the negative charge.
  • Presence of strong -I / -M groups (carbonyl, NO2NO_2, CNCN, halogens, etc.) that withdraw electron density and lower the charge density on carbon.
  • Hybridisation of the charged carbon: sp \;(\text{50 % }s) \gt sp^{2} \;(\text{33 % }s) \gt sp^{3} \;(\text{25 % }s) because higher s-character holds electrons closer to the nucleus.

The five carbanions given in the question are represented schematically below (labels as per the paper):
  I. Ph−CHX2X−\ce{Ph-CH2^{-}} (benzylic)
  II. CHX2=CH−CHX2X−\ce{CH2=CH-CH2^{-}} (allylic)
  III. (CHX3)X3CX−\ce{(CH3)3C^{-}} (tert-butyl carbanion, simple alkyl, no stabilisation)
  IV. X−X22−C(COOR)=C(COOR)X2\ce{^-C(COOR)=C(COOR)2} (anion flanked by two ester / carbonyl groups; resonance with two C=OC=O units)
  V. CHX3−CHX2X−\ce{CH3-CH2^{-}} (primary alkyl)

Now examine each structure one by one.

Case IV:

The negative charge on carbon is adjacent to two carbonyl groups. It can delocalise into both of them, giving resonance forms like X−X22−C(COOR)=C(COOR)X2 ⇌O=C(−O R)−C=C(−O R)X2X−\ce{^-C(COOR)=C(COOR)2 \rightleftharpoons O=C(-O R)-C=C(-O R)2^{-}} Hence the charge is shared among three electronegative oxygen atoms in several canonical forms. The -I and -M effects of the carbonyls further pull electron density away. This combination makes IV the most stable.

Case I:

Benzylic carbanion Ph−CHX2X−\ce{Ph-CH2^{-}} can resonate with the aromatic ring, distributing the negative charge over ortho and para positions of the benzene nucleus. Six equivalent resonance structures are possible, so I is highly stabilised, but less than IV because delocalisation is only onto sp2sp^{2} carbons, not electronegative oxygens.

Case II:

Allylic carbanion CHX2=CH−CHX2X−\ce{CH2=CH-CH2^{-}} has two resonance structures: CHX2=CH−CHX2X− ⇌X−CHX2−CH=CHX2\ce{CH2=CH-CH2^{-} \rightleftharpoons ^-CH2-CH=CH2} Delocalisation is limited to two sp2sp^{2} carbons; no electronegative atoms participate. Hence II is stabilised, but weaker than I.

Case V:

Primary alkyl carbanion CHX3−CHX2X−\ce{CH3-CH2^{-}} is an sp3sp^{3} carbanion with no resonance and only a weak inductive effect from one methyl group (actually destabilising). It is therefore much less stable than the allylic system.

Case III:

Tert-butyl carbanion (CHX3)X3CX−\ce{(CH3)3C^{-}} has three electron-donating methyl groups that intensify the negative charge (hyperconjugation works in reverse for carbanions and is destabilising). It is also sp3sp^{3} and completely localised; hence it is the least stable of the lot.

Combining the above discussions, the decreasing order of stability is:
IV>I>II>V>III\text{IV} \gt \text{I} \gt \text{II} \gt \text{V} \gt \text{III}

Therefore, the correct choice is
Option D which is: IV > I > II > V > III.

Tagged Reactive intermediates and rearrangements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicReactive intermediates and rearrangements
TypeMultiple choice