RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2025 · 22 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2025 Chemistry question — Reactive intermediates and rearrangements

The most stable carbocation from the following is :

SOLUTION

Carbocation stability is governed mainly by two effects: (i) resonance delocalisation of the positive charge and (ii) hyperconjugation/inductive donation from adjacent C−HC-H or C−CC-C bonds. When both effects are possible, resonance is much more powerful than hyperconjugation.

Step 1 - Write the skeletal formulae of the four given carbocations.
Option A : (CH3)3C+\left(CH_3\right)_3C^{+} (tert-butyl, a simple 3° alkyl carbocation)
Option B : C6H5CH2+C_6H_5CH_2^{+} (benzyl carbocation)
Option C : (C6H5)3C+(C_6H_5)_3C^{+} (triphenylmethyl carbocation)
Option D : CH2  =  CH  CH2+CH_2\;=\;CH\;CH_2^{+} (allyl carbocation)

Step 2 - Analyse resonance possibilities.
• Option A has no resonance. Charge is localised on one carbon.
• Option D is an allylic cation; the positive charge delocalises over two carbons through one C=CC=C bond giving 2 major resonance forms.
• Option B is benzylic; the charge can resonate into the aromatic ring, producing 5 additional Kekulé structures (total 6).
• Option C is triphenylmethyl; the charge can be delocalised independently into each of the three phenyl rings. Each ring contributes 5 extra structures, so there are 1+3×5=161 + 3 \times 5 = 16 significant resonance contributors. Thus the positive charge is spread over a very large π-system.

Step 3 - Consider hyperconjugation and inductive effects.
• Option A possesses nine β-hydrogens, giving nine hyperconjugative structures, but lacks resonance.
• Options B and D have only two β-hydrogens each, so hyperconjugation is much weaker than in Option A; however their resonance makes them more stable than A.
• Option C, besides enormous resonance, still has three benzylic β-hydrogens; hyperconjugation adds a small extra stabilisation.

Step 4 - Rank the overall stability.
Because resonance >> hyperconjugation, the order is
triphenylmethyl  >  benzyl  >  allyl  >  tert-butyl\text{triphenylmethyl} \; \gt \; \text{benzyl} \; \gt \; \text{allyl} \; \gt \; \text{tert-butyl}

Hence the most stable carbocation among the four is the triphenylmethyl carbocation.

Option C which is: triphenylmethyl carbocation

Tagged Reactive intermediates and rearrangements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicReactive intermediates and rearrangements
TypeMultiple choice