Effervescence of CO2 with aqueous NaHCO3 is observed only when the organic compound can donate a proton more acidic than the first proton of carbonic acid H2CO3.
The equilibrium that decides the test is
HA+NaHCO3⇌NaA+H2CO3⇌NaA+CO2↑+H2O
For the reaction to proceed to the right, the acid strength order must be pKa(HA)<pKa(H2CO3)(≈6.4).
Now examine each option:
Case A: Benzoic acid,
C6H5COOH
pKa≈4.2<6.4 ⇒ reacts with
NaHCO3, brisk effervescence.
Case B: p-Nitrobenzoic acid,
p-O2N−C6H4COOH
The strongly -NO2 group withdraws electrons, making the acid still stronger,
pKa≈3.4. Hence it reacts even more readily with
NaHCO3.
Case C: Salicylic acid (o-hydroxybenzoic acid),
o-HO−C6H4COOH
Intramolecular H-bonding stabilises its conjugate base and the acid is strong,
pKa≈2.97. Therefore it also gives effervescence.
Case D: p-Cresol (p-methylphenol),
p-CH3−C6H4OH
This compound is a phenol, not a carboxylic acid. Phenolic -OH is much less acidic (
pKa≈10 ) than carbonic acid, hence
NaHCO3 cannot deprotonate it. No
CO2 gets evolved.
Thus the compound least likely to give effervescence of CO2 with aqueous NaHCO3 is the phenol in Option D.
Final answer: Option D which is: p-Cresol (or any phenolic compound shown in Option D).