A compound is aromatic only if it satisfies all of the following conditions:
- It must be cyclic.
- It must be planar.
- It must be completely conjugated, with continuous overlap of p-orbitals.
- It must contain (4n+2) π electrons, where n is a non-negative integer.
Systems that are cyclic, planar, and fully conjugated but contain 4n π electrons are anti-aromatic and are considered not aromatic in this question.
Now, evaluate each structure:
- (a) Cyclopentadienyl anion
- π electrons = 2 double bonds =4 electrons + one carbanion lone pair =2 electrons.
- Total π electrons = 4+2=6.
- It is cyclic, planar, fully conjugated, and satisfies Hückel's rule.
- Result: Aromatic.
- (b) Cyclopentadienyl cation
- π electrons = 2 double bonds =4 electrons + empty p-orbital =0 electrons.
- Total π electrons = 4.
- It is fully conjugated but contains 4n π electrons.
- Result: Not aromatic.
- (c) Cyclobutadienyl dication
- π electrons = 1 double bond =2 electrons + two empty p-orbitals =0 electrons.
- Total π electrons = 2.
- It is cyclic, planar, fully conjugated, and satisfies Hückel's rule.
- Result: Aromatic.
- (d) Cyclobutadienyl dianion
- π electrons = 1 double bond =2 electrons + two lone pairs =4 electrons.
- Total π electrons = 2+4=6.
- It is cyclic, planar, fully conjugated, and satisfies Hückel's rule.
- Result: Aromatic.
- (e) Cycloheptatrienyl cation (Tropylium ion)
- π electrons = 3 double bonds =6 electrons + empty p-orbital =0 electrons.
- Total π electrons = 6.
- It is cyclic, planar, fully conjugated, and satisfies Hückel's rule.
- Result: Aromatic.
- (f) Cyclooctatetraene
- π electrons = 4 double bonds =8 electrons.
- If planar, it would possess 4n π electrons and be anti-aromatic.
- To avoid this instability, it adopts a non-planar tub-shaped conformation, destroying continuous conjugation.
- Result: Not aromatic.
- (g) Cyclobutadiene
- π electrons = 2 double bonds =4 electrons.
- It is fully conjugated but contains 4n π electrons.
- Result: Not aromatic.
- (h) Cyclopropenyl cation
- π electrons = 1 double bond =2 electrons + empty p-orbital =0 electrons.
- Total π electrons = 2.
- It is cyclic, planar, fully conjugated, and satisfies Hückel's rule.
- Result: Aromatic.
Therefore,
- Aromatic: a, c, d, e, h
- Not aromatic: b, f, g
Hence, the correct option is (D).