RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2009TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2009 Chemistry question — Reactive intermediates and rearrangements

Arrange the carbanions, (CH3)3Cˉ,CˉCl3,(CH3)2CˉH,C6H5CˉH2(CH_3)_3\bar{C}, \bar{C}Cl_3, (CH_3)_2\bar{C}H, C_6H_5\bar{C}H_2, in order of their decreasing stability :

SOLUTION

A carbanion carries a negative charge on carbon. Its stability is governed mainly by two factors:
1. Electron-withdrawing effects (−I/−M) and resonance delocalisation that can disperse the negative charge - these increase stability.
2. Electron-donating +I/+H (hyperconjugation) effects of alkyl groups that push electron density towards an already negative carbon - these decrease stability.

Let us examine each species.

Case 1: CˉCl3\bar{C}Cl_3 (trichloromethyl carbanion)
Each chlorine has a strong −I (inductive electron-withdrawing) effect. Three such groups pull electron density away from the carbanionic carbon and greatly stabilise the charge. No competing +I groups are present. Hence this is expected to be the most stable of the given set.

Case 2: C6H5CˉH2C_6H_5\bar{C}H_2 (benzyl carbanion)
The lone pair on the carbanionic carbon can overlap with the π-system of the benzene ring. Consequently, the negative charge is delocalised over the ring via resonance: CˉH2−C6H5  ⇌  CH2=C6H5ˉ\bar{C}H_2 - C_6H_5 \;\rightleftharpoons\; CH_2 = C_6H_5\bar{} etc. This resonance dispersion strongly stabilises the anion. Although the phenyl ring is weakly −I/−M overall, the resonance delocalisation dominates, making the benzyl anion highly stable, but still somewhat less than CˉCl3\bar{C}Cl_3 where three strong −I groups act continuously.

Case 3: (CH3)2CˉH(CH_3)_2\bar{C}H (isopropyl carbanion)
Two methyl groups exert a +I effect and also offer hyperconjugation. Both donate electron density, which destabilises the already negative carbon. With only two methyls this destabilisation is moderate.

Case 4: (CH3)3Cˉ(CH_3)_3\bar{C} (tert-butyl carbanion)
Here three methyl groups donate electron density (+I and +H) to the carbanionic carbon. This is the maximum alkyl electron donation among the given examples, so it is the least stable of the four.

Combining the analyses:

CˉCl3  >  C6H5CˉH2  >  (CH3)2CˉH  >  (CH3)3Cˉ\bar{C}Cl_3 \; \gt \; C_6H_5\bar{C}H_2 \; \gt \; (CH_3)_2\bar{C}H \; \gt \; (CH_3)_3\bar{C}

Thus the correct decreasing stability order matches Option C.

Final Answer: Option C which is: CˉCl3>C6H5CˉH2>(CH3)2CˉH>(CH3)3Cˉ\bar{C}Cl_3 > C_6H_5\bar{C}H_2 > (CH_3)_2\bar{C}H > (CH_3)_3\bar{C}

Tagged Reactive intermediates and rearrangements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicReactive intermediates and rearrangements
TypeMultiple choice