RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2004TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2004 Chemistry question — Optical isomerism and chirality

Which of the following will have meso-isomer also?

SOLUTION

Meso Compounds

A meso compound is an acyclic or cyclic molecule that contains two or more asymmetric carbon atoms (chiral centers) but is completely achiral (optically inactive) as a whole because it possesses an internal plane of symmetry (σ\sigma) or a center of inversion (ii).

Rule of Thumb: For an open-chain molecule to have a meso-isomer, it must be symmetric—meaning both halves of the molecule must have identical structural connectivity and the exact same set of substituents attached to equivalent chiral centers.


  • Option A: 2-Chlorobutane

    CH3−C∗HCl−CH2−CH3\text{CH}_3-\text{C}^*\text{HCl}-\text{CH}_2-\text{CH}_3

    This molecule contains only one chiral center (C2\text{C}_2). A compound must contain at least two chiral centers to form an internal plane of symmetry. Therefore, it cannot form a meso-isomer.

    Result: No meso-isomer


  • Option B: 2-Hydroxypropanoic acid (Lactic acid)

    CH3−C∗H(OH)−COOH\text{CH}_3-\text{C}^*\text{H(OH)}-\text{COOH}

    This molecule has only one chiral center (C2\text{C}_2) bonded to four different groups (−H-\text{H}, −OH-\text{OH}, −CH3-\text{CH}_3, and −COOH-\text{COOH}). Hence, a meso configuration is impossible.

    Result: No meso-isomer


  • Option C: 2,3-Dichloropentane

    CH3−C∗HCl−C∗HCl−CH2−CH3\text{CH}_3-\text{C}^*\text{HCl}-\text{C}^*\text{HCl}-\text{CH}_2-\text{CH}_3

    This molecule has two chiral centers (C2\text{C}_2 and C3\text{C}_3). However, the molecule is structurally unsymmetric because one end terminates in a methyl group (−CH3-\text{CH}_3) while the other terminates in an ethyl group (−CH2CH3-\text{CH}_2\text{CH}_3). Because the two halves are non-identical, no plane of symmetry can exist in any conformation.

    Result: No meso-isomer


  • Option D: 2,3-Dichlorobutane

    CH3−C∗HCl−C∗HCl−CH3\text{CH}_3-\text{C}^*\text{HCl}-\text{C}^*\text{HCl}-\text{CH}_3

    This molecule contains two chiral centers (C2\text{C}_2 and C3\text{C}_3) and is completely symmetric. Both carbon atoms are bonded to the exact same four groups: −H-\text{H}, −Cl-\text{Cl}, −CH3-\text{CH}_3, and a −CH(Cl)CH3-\text{CH(Cl)CH}_3 group.

    In its (2R,3S)(2R, 3S) configuration, an internal plane of symmetry cuts directly through the central C–C\text{C}\text{--}\text{C} bond, reflecting one half of the molecule perfectly onto the other.

    Result: Possesses a meso-isomer [Count = 1]



Only 2,3-dichlorobutane satisfies the requirements of having a symmetrical carbon skeleton with equivalent chiral centers to yield a meso-isomer.

Answer: Option D — 2,3-dichlorobutane

Tagged Optical isomerism and chirality. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicOptical isomerism and chirality
TypeMultiple choice