Given below are two statements :
Statement I : In
the carbocation is stabilised by +R effect of group.
Statement II : In
the carbanion is stabilised by effect of group.
To evaluate the validity of the given statements, we analyze the electronic effects exerted by the substituent groups on the corresponding reactive intermediates.
The first statement states that the carbocation is stabilized by the effect of the group. A carbocation is an electron-deficient species and is stabilized by substituents capable of donating electron density. The methoxy group contains a lone pair of electrons on the oxygen atom, which can participate in resonance with the aromatic ring. Through this (or ) effect, electron density is delocalized toward the positively charged center, thereby stabilizing the carbocation. Hence, Statement I is true.
The second statement claims that the carbanion is stabilized by the effect of the group. A carbanion carries excess electron density and is stabilized by electron-withdrawing substituents. The nitro group is a strong electron-withdrawing group that exhibits both and effects. Through its effect, it withdraws electron density from the aromatic system and delocalizes the negative charge by resonance, thereby stabilizing the carbanion. Hence, Statement II is also true.
Therefore, both the resonance-donating effect of the methoxy group stabilizing a carbocation and the resonance-withdrawing effect of the nitro group stabilizing a carbanion are valid principles of organic chemistry.
Correct Answer: Both Statement I and Statement II are true.
Tagged Reactive intermediates and rearrangements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.