First, we recall the definition of an acidic buffer. An acidic buffer is a solution that contains a weak acid and its conjugate base (usually provided by a salt of the weak acid). Such a mixture resists changes in pH when small amounts of strong acid or base are added. Mathematically, the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation for an acidic buffer is stated as
pH=pKa+log10([acid][salt]).
Hence, to identify which option forms an acidic buffer, we must look for a final mixture that simultaneously contains a weak acid, for example CH3COOH, and its salt with a strong base, for example CH3COONa. We now examine each option one by one, carefully calculating moles so that every algebraic step is visible.
Option A. 100 mL of 0.1 M CH3COOH and 100 mL of 0.1 M NaOH.
We determine the number of moles present before mixing:
Moles of CH3COOH=0.1M×0.100L=0.010mol.
Moles of NaOH=0.1M×0.100L=0.010mol.
Because NaOH is a strong base, it completely neutralises the weak acid.
Neutralisation reaction:
CH3COOH+NaOH⟶CH3COONa+H2O.
Equal moles react, so both 0.010 mol are consumed, leaving
0mol CH3COOH and 0.010mol CH3COONa.
No weak acid remains; only its salt is present. Therefore no acidic buffer is produced in Option A.
Option B. 100 mL of 0.1 M HCl and 200 mL of 0.1 M NaCl.
HCl is a strong acid, not a weak one. Furthermore, NaCl is a neutral salt and is not the conjugate base of any weak acid present in the solution. Consequently, the mixture is simply a diluted strong acid solution, not a buffer. Hence Option B does not give an acidic buffer.
Option C. 100 mL of 0.1 M CH3COOH and 200 mL of 0.1 M NaOH.
Again, calculate moles:
Moles of CH3COOH=0.1M×0.100L=0.010mol,
Moles of NaOH=0.1M×0.200L=0.020mol.
Neutralisation occurs according to the same reaction used in Option A. The limiting reagent is the acid (0.010 mol). After complete reaction, the leftover base is
0.020mol−0.010mol=0.010mol NaOH.
The solution therefore contains excess strong base, making the medium decidedly basic. Since a buffer requires both weak acid and its salt, and here no weak acid is left, Option C also fails to produce an acidic buffer.
Option D. 100 mL of 0.1 M HCl and 200 mL of 0.1 M CH3COONa.
We again compute moles precisely:
Moles of HCl=0.1M×0.100L=0.010mol,
Moles of CH3COONa=0.1M×0.200L=0.020mol.
Now the strong acid HCl reacts with the salt of the weak acid as follows:
HCl+CH3COONa⟶CH3COOH+NaCl.
Mole-by-mole subtraction shows the change:
Initial Reacted Remaining Formed [HCl]=0.010mol,[CH3COONa]=0.020mol.0.010mol HCl with 0.010mol CH3COONa.[HCl]=0mol,[CH3COONa]=0.020−0.010=0.010mol.[CH3COOH]=0.010mol.$
After reaction, the solution now contains 0.010 mol of the weak acid CH3COOH and 0.010 mol of its conjugate-base salt CH3COONa in the final total volume
Vfinal=100mL+200mL=300mL=0.300L.
Because both the weak acid and its salt are simultaneously present, the mixture satisfies the buffer condition. Specifically, it is an acidic buffer because the pH will be <7 (the weak acid component dominates over the weak base part of the conjugate pair).
Therefore, only Option D yields an acidic buffer.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.