JEE MAIN 2013 · 22 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED
JEE Main 2013 Chemistry question — Solubility product and common ion effect
Which one of the following arrangements represents the correct order of solubilities of sparingly soluble salts Hg2Cl2, Cr2(SO4)3, BaSO4 and CrCl3 respectively?
SOLUTION
To determine the correct order of solubilities for the sparingly soluble salts Hg2Cl2, Cr2(SO4)3, BaSO4, and CrCl3, we need to compare their molar solubilities. The molar solubility, denoted as S, is the number of moles of the salt that dissolve per liter of solution. For sparingly soluble salts, the solubility product constant (Ksp) relates to the solubility S through the dissociation reaction.
First, we write the dissociation reactions and the corresponding Ksp expressions in terms of S:
For Hg2Cl2:
The dissociation is Hg2Cl2→Hg22++2Cl−.
If solubility is S, then [Hg22+]=S and [Cl−]=2S.
So, Ksp=[Hg22+][Cl−]2=(S)(2S)2=4S3.
Therefore, S=(4Ksp)31.
For Cr2(SO4)3:
The dissociation is Cr2(SO4)3→2Cr3++3SO42−.
If solubility is S, then [Cr3+]=2S and [SO42−]=3S.
So, Ksp=[Cr3+]2[SO42−]3=(2S)2(3S)3=4S2×27S3=108S5.
Therefore, S=(108Ksp)51.
For BaSO4:
The dissociation is BaSO4→Ba2++SO42−.
If solubility is S, then [Ba2+]=S and [SO42−]=S.
So, Ksp=[Ba2+][SO42−]=S×S=S2.
Therefore, S=Ksp.
For CrCl3:
The dissociation is CrCl3→Cr3++3Cl−.
If solubility is S, then [Cr3+]=S and [Cl−]=3S.
So, Ksp=[Cr3+][Cl−]3=(S)(3S)3=27S4.
Therefore, S=(27Ksp)41.
Now, to compare the solubilities, we assume that the Ksp values for these salts are of the same order of magnitude. This is a common approach when exact Ksp values are not provided, as the exponent in the solubility expression dominates the comparison.
Expressing S in terms of Ksp:
SBaSO4=(Ksp)21
SHg2Cl2=(4Ksp)31=(Ksp)31×(41)31
SCrCl3=(27Ksp)41=(Ksp)41×(271)41
SCr2(SO4)3=(108Ksp)51=(Ksp)51×(1081)51
Since Ksp is assumed to be similar for all salts, the solubility S depends on the exponent of Ksp and the constant divisor. Higher exponents result in larger S for the same Ksp. The exponents are:
21=0.5 for BaSO4
31≈0.333 for Hg2Cl2
41=0.25 for CrCl3
51=0.2 for Cr2(SO4)3
Ordering by the exponents: 0.5>0.333>0.25>0.2. Thus, the solubility order from highest to lowest is BaSO4>Hg2Cl2>CrCl3>Cr2(SO4)3.
Comparing with the options:
Option A: BaSO4>Hg2Cl2>Cr2(SO4)3>CrCl3 — incorrect, as CrCl3 should be greater than Cr2(SO4)3.