When the salt AB2 dissolves, it produces one divalent cation A2+ and two anions B−:
AB2→A2++2B−
The salt XY produces one monovalent cation X+ and one anion Y−:
XY→X++Y−
The required precipitate is AY2, which dissociates as
AY2⇌A2++2Y−
Hence, the solubility-product expression is
Ksp=[A2+][Y−]2
Let the initial molarities of AB2 and XY be C1 and C2 respectively (as given in each option). The two solutions are mixed in equal volumes, so the total volume becomes double. Every concentration therefore becomes half.
After mixing:
[A2+]=2C1 (comes only from AB2)
[Y−]=2C2 (comes only from XY)
The ionic product (IP) for AY2 just after mixing is
IP=(2C1)(2C2)2=8C1C22 −(1)
Precipitation of AY2 occurs when IP>Ksp.
Case 1: Option A (
C1=3.6×10−3M,C2=5.0×10−4M )
Substitute in (1):
IP=8(3.6×10−3)(5.0×10−4)2=83.6×10−3×25×10−8=89.0×10−10=1.1×10−10
Since 1.1×10−10<5.2×10−7, no precipitate.
Case 2: Option B (
C1=2.0×10−4M,C2=0.8×10−3M )
IP=8(2.0×10−4)(8.0×10−4)2=82.0×10−4×64×10−8=81.28×10−10=1.6×10−11
Again 1.6×10−11<5.2×10−7, so no precipitate.
Case 3: Option C (
C1=2.0×10−2M,C2=2.0×10−2M )
IP=8(2.0×10−2)(2.0×10−2)2=82.0×10−2×4.0×10−4=88.0×10−6=1.0×10−6
Now 1.0×10−6>5.2×10−7, so IP>Ksp and precipitate of AY2 will form.
Case 4: Option D (
C1=1.5×10−4M,C2=1.5×10−3M )
IP=8(1.5×10−4)(1.5×10−3)2=81.5×10−4×2.25×10−6=83.375×10−10=4.2×10−11
Since 4.2×10−11<5.2×10−7, no precipitate.
The only combination that satisfies IP>Ksp is Option C.
Answer: Option C