JEE Main 2010 Chemistry question — Ionisation of weak electrolytes and Ostwald's dilution law
In aqueous solution the ionization constants for carbonic acid are K1=4.2×10−7 and K2=4.8×10−11. Select the correct statement for a saturated 0.034M solution of the carbonic acid.
SOLUTION
For carbonic acid H2CO3 the two successive ionisations in water are
The formal (analytical) concentration of the acid is C0=0.034M.
Because both ionisation constants are very small, only a small fraction of H2CO3 dissociates, so we may take [H2CO3]≈C0 in the first approximation.
Step 1 : First-step dissociation
Let x be the concentration produced by the first step:
H2CO3⇌H+(x)+HCO3−(x)
Using K1,
K1=[H2CO3][H+][HCO3−]≈C0x2
so
x≈K1C0=(4.2×10−7)(0.034)≈1.43×10−8≈1.2×10−4M
Step 2 : Second-step dissociation
Let y be the amount of HCO3− that dissociates further:
HCO3−⇌H+(+y)+CO32−(+y)
At equilibrium
[H+]=x+y,[HCO3−]=x−y,[CO32−]=y
Using K2,
K2=[HCO3−][H+][CO32−]=x−y(x+y)y
Because the second dissociation is much weaker, y≪x, giving
K2≈y⟹y≈4.8×10−11M
Step 3 : Comparing species
Final concentrations (to the significant figures needed for comparison): [H+]=x+y≈1.2×10−4M [HCO3−]=x−y≈1.2×10−4M [CO32−]=y≈5×10−11M
The results show
• [H+] and [HCO3−] are practically the same.
• [CO32−] is many orders of magnitude smaller than either of them.
Examining the options
A. [CO32−]=0.034M ― false (actual value ≈ 5×10−11M).
B. [CO32−]>[HCO3−] ― false (it is much smaller).
C. [H+] and [HCO3−] are approximately equal ― true, both ≈ 1.2×10−4M.
D. [H+]=2[CO32−] ― false (ratio is about 2.4×106).
Hence, the correct statement is: Option C which is: The concentration of H+ and HCO3− are approximately equal.
Tagged Ionisation of weak electrolytes and Ostwald's dilution law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.