RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2006TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2006 Chemistry question — Arrhenius, Bronsted-Lowry and Lewis acid-base concepts

Which of the following statements is true?

SOLUTION

Acid strength in covalent compounds is governed mainly by two factors:
1. Ease of H+H^+ release (polarity of the H−XH-X bond and its bond strength).
2. Stability of the conjugate base that remains after the proton leaves (greater stability ⇒ stronger acid).

With these ideas, examine each statement:

Case A:

H3PO3H_3PO_3 vs H2SO3H_2SO_3
• Both are oxy-acids, but the central atoms differ. Phosphorus is less electronegative than sulphur, so the P−OP-O bond is less polar than the S−OS-O bond.
• Moreover, the conjugate base H2PO3−H_2PO_3^- is less stabilised by resonance than HSO3−HSO_3^-. Hence H2SO3H_2SO_3 is the stronger acid. Statement A is false.

Case B:

Binary hydrogen halides in water become stronger acids down the group: HF<HCl<HBr<HIHF \lt HCl \lt HBr \lt HI.
• Although FF is the most electronegative, the very strong H−FH-F bond (and partial hydrogen bonding) makes dissociation difficult.
• Therefore HF is the weakest of the common hydrogen halides in aqueous solution. Statement B is false.

Case C:

Oxo-acids of the same halogen: acid strength increases with oxidation number of the central atom because extra OO atoms pull electron density away and stabilise the conjugate base by resonance.
• ClCl oxidation states: +7+7 in HClO4HClO_4 vs +5+5 in HClO3HClO_3.
• Thus HClO4HClO_4 ≫ HClO3HClO_3 in acid strength. Statement C is false.

Case D:

Oxo-acids of nitrogen: HNO3HNO_3 (oxidation state +5+5) and HNO2HNO_2 (oxidation state +3+3). Greater oxidation state gives better delocalisation and stability of the conjugate base NO3−NO_3^- compared with NO2−NO_2^-, so HNO3HNO_3 is indeed the stronger acid. Statement D is true.

Hence the only correct statement is
Option D which is: HNO3HNO_3 is a stronger acid than HNO2HNO_2.

Tagged Arrhenius, Bronsted-Lowry and Lewis acid-base concepts. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicArrhenius, Bronsted-Lowry and Lewis acid-base concepts
TypeMultiple choice