RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — Arrhenius, Bronsted-Lowry and Lewis acid-base concepts

Which of the following is a Lewis acid?

SOLUTION

First, recall the definition of a Lewis acid and a Lewis base. According to G. N. Lewis,

Lewis acid=a species that can accept an electron pair,\text{Lewis acid} = \text{a species that can accept an electron pair},

Lewis base=a species that can donate an electron pair.\text{Lewis base} = \text{a species that can donate an electron pair}.

Now, we examine every option one by one, asking whether the central atom in each molecule has an empty orbital that can accept an electron pair.

Option A is PH3.\text{PH}_3. We note that phosphorus in PH3\text{PH}_3 has the electronic configuration [Ne] 3s23p3.[Ne]\,3s^23p^3. In the molecule, the three 3p3p electrons form σ-bonds with three hydrogens, and the remaining lone pair occupies the fourth position of a tetrahedron. All valence orbitals are filled; phosphorus does not possess an empty orbital of sufficiently low energy to accept another pair easily. Consequently, PH3\text{PH}_3 behaves as a Lewis base (because of its lone pair) rather than a Lewis acid.

Option B is NF3.\text{NF}_3. Nitrogen has the electronic configuration 1s22s22p3.1s^22s^22p^3. Just like in ammonia, nitrogen in NF3\text{NF}_3 holds one lone pair. Again, this lone pair makes NF3\text{NF}_3 a potential Lewis base, while no vacant orbital is available on nitrogen to accept an electron pair. Therefore, NF3\text{NF}_3 is not a Lewis acid.

Option C is NaH.\text{NaH}. Sodium hydride is best described as an ionic solid composed of Na+\text{Na}^+ and H−\text{H}^- ions. The hydride ion H−\text{H}^- is a powerful electron-pair donor, hence unquestionably a Lewis base. The Na+\text{Na}^+ ion, while electron-deficient, usually acts as a spectator cation and does not function as a conventional Lewis acid in simple molecular interactions. Thus, NaH\text{NaH} does not qualify as a Lewis acid.

Option D is B(CH3)3.\text{B(CH}_3)_3. Boron in this molecule has the electronic configuration 1s22s22p1.1s^22s^22p^1. In B(CH3)3\text{B(CH}_3)_3, boron forms three σ-bonds with the three CH3\text{CH}_3 groups. After forming these bonds, boron possesses only six valence electrons:

Total electrons around B=3×2  (from three σ-bonds)=6<8.\text{Total electrons around B}=3\times2\;(\text{from three σ-bonds})=6<8.

This electron deficiency means boron has an empty 2p2p orbital. Because that orbital can accept an electron pair from some donor, B(CH3)3\text{B(CH}_3)_3 satisfies the definition of a Lewis acid. Indeed, trialkyl- and trialkoxy-boranes are classic textbook examples of Lewis acids, forming adducts such as B(CH3)3 ⁣: ⁣NH3\text{B(CH}_3)_3\!:\!NH_3 when a Lewis base like ammonia donates its lone pair into boron’s vacant orbital.

Comparing all four choices, only B(CH3)3\text{B(CH}_3)_3 clearly possesses a vacant orbital capable of accepting an electron pair. Hence it alone behaves as a Lewis acid among the given compounds.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Arrhenius, Bronsted-Lowry and Lewis acid-base concepts. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicArrhenius, Bronsted-Lowry and Lewis acid-base concepts
TypeMultiple choice