RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 08 APR S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Stratospheric pollution and ozone depletion

Assertion: Ozone is destroyed by CFCs in the upper stratosphere.
Reason: Ozone holes increase the amount of UV radiation reaching the earth.

SOLUTION

We begin by reading the two statements carefully.

Assertion. “Ozone is destroyed by CFCs in the upper stratosphere.”

Reason. “Ozone holes increase the amount of UV radiation reaching the earth.”

Let us analyse the scientific facts one after another, using well-known atmospheric chemistry.

First, we recall the definition of chlorofluorocarbons. These are molecules such as CFCl3,  CF2Cl2\text{CFCl}_3,\; \text{CF}_2\text{Cl}_2 that are extremely stable in the lower atmosphere. Because of this stability they are able to drift up to the stratosphere without being degraded.

In the upper stratosphere, however, they encounter high-energy ultraviolet radiation (hνh\nu). The radiation breaks the C-Cl\text{C-Cl} bond according to the photolysis reaction

CFCl3+hν  ⟶  CFCl2+Cl∙.\text{CFCl}_3 + h\nu \;\longrightarrow\; \text{CFCl}_2 + \text{Cl}^\bullet.

The chlorine free radical Cl∙\text{Cl}^\bullet produced in this way acts catalytically to destroy ozone. The two elementary steps commonly written are

Cl∙+O3  ⟶  ClO∙+O2,\text{Cl}^\bullet + \text{O}_3 \;\longrightarrow\; \text{ClO}^\bullet + \text{O}_2,

ClO∙+O  ⟶  Cl∙+O2.\text{ClO}^\bullet + \text{O} \;\longrightarrow\; \text{Cl}^\bullet + \text{O}_2.

Adding the two reactions and cancelling the unchanged Cl∙\text{Cl}^\bullet radical, we obtain the net effect

O3+O  ⟶  2O2,\text{O}_3 + \text{O} \;\longrightarrow\; 2\text{O}_2,

showing unequivocally that the presence of CFCs brings about ozone destruction. Therefore, the Assertion is true.

Next, we examine the Reason. Ozone present in the stratosphere absorbs a large fraction of the biologically harmful ultraviolet-B (280-315 nm280\text{-}315\,\text{nm}) radiation. If the ozone concentration is reduced (that is, if an “ozone hole” forms), the shielding effect weakens. Consequently, more UV-B reaches the troposphere and eventually the earth’s surface. Hence, the Reason statement “Ozone holes increase the amount of UV radiation reaching the earth” is scientifically correct. Therefore, the Reason is also true.

We must now decide whether the Reason explains the Assertion. The Assertion deals with the cause of ozone destruction (action of CFCs), while the Reason speaks about one of the consequences of that destruction (enhanced UV radiation). A correct explanation would have to link CFCs to ozone depletion directly, for example by mentioning chlorine radicals. The given Reason does not do that; it merely lists an effect that follows after the depletion has occurred. Hence, although both statements are correct, the Reason is not the correct explanation of the Assertion.

According to the option list, this situation corresponds to Option A: “Assertion and reason are correct, but the reason is not the explanation for the assertion.”

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Stratospheric pollution and ozone depletion. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStratospheric pollution and ozone depletion
TypeMultiple choice