RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 02 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — Water pollution

A water sample has ppm level concentration of following anions
F−^{-} = 10; SO42−_{4}^{2-} = 100; NO3−_{3}^{-} = 50
The anion/anions that make/makes the water sample unsuitable for drinking is/are

SOLUTION

To decide whether any of the given anions make the sample unfit for drinking, we first recall the generally accepted maximum permissible limits for potable water (as recommended by bodies such as BIS or WHO).

For each anion we have the following limits:

Fluoride ion, F−:1.5 ppm (mg L−1)\text{Fluoride ion, }F^- : 1.5\ \text{ppm (mg}\,\text{L}^{-1})

Sulfate ion, SO42−:250 ppm\text{Sulfate ion, }SO_4^{2-} : 250\ \text{ppm}

Nitrate ion, NO3−:50 ppm\text{Nitrate ion, }NO_3^- : 50\ \text{ppm}

Now we compare the given concentrations with these limits one by one.

For fluoride we have

Given concentration of F−=10 ppm\text{Given concentration of }F^- = 10\ \text{ppm}

Permissible limit=1.5 ppm\text{Permissible limit} = 1.5\ \text{ppm}

Since 10 ppm>1.5 ppm,10\ \text{ppm} > 1.5\ \text{ppm}, the fluoride level is far above the allowed value, so fluoride definitely makes the water unsuitable.

For sulfate we have

Given concentration of SO42−=100 ppm\text{Given concentration of }SO_4^{2-} = 100\ \text{ppm}

Permissible limit=250 ppm\text{Permissible limit} = 250\ \text{ppm}

Because 100 ppm<250 ppm,100\ \text{ppm} < 250\ \text{ppm}, the sulfate level lies well within the safe range; hence sulfate is not a cause for rejection.

For nitrate we have

Given concentration of NO3−=50 ppm\text{Given concentration of }NO_3^- = 50\ \text{ppm}

Permissible limit=50 ppm\text{Permissible limit} = 50\ \text{ppm}

Here 50 ppm=50 ppm,50\ \text{ppm} = 50\ \text{ppm}, i.e. the nitrate content is exactly at the upper permissible boundary. Water containing an ion exactly at its maximum prescribed level is still regarded as acceptable. Therefore nitrate alone does not render the water unfit.

Summarizing these comparisons:

F−:Exceeds limitF^- : \text{Exceeds limit}

SO42−:Within limitSO_4^{2-} : \text{Within limit}

NO3−:At limit (acceptable)NO_3^- : \text{At limit (acceptable)}

Consequently, out of the three anions listed, only fluoride makes the water sample unsuitable for drinking.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Water pollution. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicWater pollution
TypeMultiple choice