Consider the following standard electrode potentials ( in volts) in aqueous solution:
| Element | ||
|---|---|---|
| Al | ||
| Tl |
First, we recall the definition of the standard reduction potential. For a general half-reaction of the form the symbol tells us how readily the oxidised species gains the electrons.
More positive reduction is easy, so the oxidised species is less stable and prefers to be reduced.
More negative reduction is difficult, so the oxidised species is more stable and prefers to remain as it is.
Now we write the relevant half-reactions given in the table.
For aluminium:
For thallium:
Let us discuss the stability of each oxidation state.
For aluminium, the potential is quite negative, so the reduction of is hard; therefore is comparatively stable. The potential for is positive, so is easily reduced to metallic aluminium and is consequently less stable than .
For thallium, the potential for is strongly positive, so is easily reduced and is not very stable. The potential for is negative, so the reduction of is relatively difficult and is the more stable oxidation state for thallium.
We now compare the species mentioned in the options.
is less positive (more negative) than . Because a more negative potential means a lower tendency to get reduced, remains as it is more readily than ; thus is more stable than .
The other options conflict with the sign logic we have just applied: is not more stable than , is not more stable than , and is not more stable than .
Therefore, only the statement “ is more stable than ” is correct.
Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.
Tagged Electrode potentials, electrochemical series and cell EMF. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.