RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 08 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — Electrode potentials, electrochemical series and cell EMF

Consider the following standard electrode potentials (E°E° in volts) in aqueous solution:

ElementM3+/MM^{3+}/MM+/MM^+/M
Al−1.66-1.66+0.55+0.55
Tl+1.26+1.26−0.34-0.34

Based on these data, which of the following statements is correct?
SOLUTION

First, we recall the definition of the standard reduction potential. For a general half-reaction of the form Oxn++ne−→Red,\text{Ox}^{n+}+ne^- \rightarrow \text{Red}, the symbol E∘E^\circ tells us how readily the oxidised species Oxn+\text{Ox}^{n+} gains the electrons.

More positive E∘E^\circ  ⇒\Rightarrow  reduction is easy, so the oxidised species is less stable and prefers to be reduced.
More negative E∘E^\circ  ⇒\Rightarrow  reduction is difficult, so the oxidised species is more stable and prefers to remain as it is.

Now we write the relevant half-reactions given in the table.

For aluminium:

Al3++3e−→Al,E∘=−1.66 VAl^{3+}+3e^- \rightarrow Al,\qquad E^\circ=-1.66\ \text{V} Al++e−→Al,E∘=+0.55 VAl^{+}+e^- \rightarrow Al,\qquad E^\circ=+0.55\ \text{V}

For thallium:

Tl3++3e−→Tl,E∘=+1.26 VTl^{3+}+3e^- \rightarrow Tl,\qquad E^\circ=+1.26\ \text{V} Tl++e−→Tl,E∘=−0.34 VTl^{+}+e^- \rightarrow Tl,\qquad E^\circ=-0.34\ \text{V}

Let us discuss the stability of each oxidation state.

For aluminium, the potential −1.66 V-1.66\text{ V} is quite negative, so the reduction of Al3+Al^{3+} is hard; therefore Al3+Al^{3+} is comparatively stable. The potential +0.55 V+0.55\text{ V} for Al+Al^{+} is positive, so Al+Al^{+} is easily reduced to metallic aluminium and is consequently less stable than Al3+Al^{3+}.

For thallium, the potential +1.26 V+1.26\text{ V} for Tl3+Tl^{3+} is strongly positive, so Tl3+Tl^{3+} is easily reduced and is not very stable. The potential −0.34 V-0.34\text{ V} for Tl+Tl^{+} is negative, so the reduction of Tl+Tl^{+} is relatively difficult and Tl+Tl^{+} is the more stable oxidation state for thallium.

We now compare the species mentioned in the options.

Tl+:E∘=−0.34 VTl^{+}: E^\circ=-0.34\text{ V} is less positive (more negative) than Al+:E∘=+0.55 VAl^{+}: E^\circ=+0.55\text{ V}. Because a more negative potential means a lower tendency to get reduced, Tl+Tl^{+} remains as it is more readily than Al+Al^{+}; thus Tl+Tl^{+} is more stable than Al+Al^{+}.

The other options conflict with the sign logic we have just applied: Al+Al^{+} is not more stable than Al3+Al^{3+}, Tl3+Tl^{3+} is not more stable than Al3+Al^{3+}, and Tl+Tl^{+} is not more stable than Al3+Al^{3+}.

Therefore, only the statement “Tl+Tl^{+} is more stable than Al+Al^{+}” is correct.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.

Tagged Electrode potentials, electrochemical series and cell EMF. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicElectrode potentials, electrochemical series and cell EMF
TypeMultiple choice