RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Conductance, conductivity and molar conductivity

The equation that is incorrect is:

SOLUTION

First, recall Kohlrausch’s Law of Independent Migration of Ions, which states

Λm0(electrolyte)=λ+0+λ−0\Lambda_m^0(\text{electrolyte}) = \lambda^0_+ + \lambda^0_-

where λ+0\lambda^0_+ is the limiting molar ionic conductivity of the cation and λ−0\lambda^0_- is that of the anion. With this law we can expand every limiting molar conductivity appearing in the options into the sum of its two ionic parts and then compare both sides algebraically, term by term.

Option A proposes

(Λm0)KBr−(Λm0)NaCl  =  (Λm0)KBr−(Λm0)KCl(\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{KBr}} - (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaCl}} \;=\; (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{KBr}} - (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{KCl}}

Using Kohlrausch’s law on each symbol:

(Λm0)KBr=λK0+λBr0,(Λm0)NaCl=λNa0+λCl0,(Λm0)KCl=λK0+λCl0.\begin{aligned} (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{KBr}} &= \lambda_{\text{K}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Br}}^0,\\ (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaCl}} &= \lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0,\\ (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{KCl}} &= \lambda_{\text{K}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0. \end{aligned}$

Now substitute:

LHS=(λK0+λBr0)−(λNa0+λCl0)=λK0−λNa0+λBr0−λCl0,\begin{aligned} \text{LHS} &= (\lambda_{\text{K}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Br}}^0) - (\lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0)\\[4pt] &= \lambda_{\text{K}}^0 - \lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Br}}^0 - \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0, \end{aligned}$

RHS=(λK0+λBr0)−(λK0+λCl0)=λBr0−λCl0.\begin{aligned} \text{RHS} &= (\lambda_{\text{K}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Br}}^0) - (\lambda_{\text{K}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0)\\[4pt] &= \lambda_{\text{Br}}^0 - \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0. \end{aligned}$

The two sides will be equal only if λK0−λNa0=0,\lambda_{\text{K}}^0 - \lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 = 0, i.e. λK0=λNa0,\lambda_{\text{K}}^0 = \lambda_{\text{Na}}^0, which is not true experimentally. Therefore option A is incorrect.

Option B states

(Λm0)KG−(Λm0)KQ  =  (Λm0)NaG−(Λm0)NaQ.(\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{KG}} - (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{KQ}} \;=\; (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaG}} - (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaQ}}.

Expanding each term (with G and Q as arbitrary anions):

LHS=(λK0+λG0)−(λK0+λQ0)=λG0−λQ0,RHS=(λNa0+λG0)−(λNa0+λQ0)=λG0−λQ0.\begin{aligned} \text{LHS} &= (\lambda_{\text{K}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{G}}^0) - (\lambda_{\text{K}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Q}}^0)\\[4pt] &= \lambda_{\text{G}}^0 - \lambda_{\text{Q}}^0,\\[8pt] \text{RHS} &= (\lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{G}}^0) - (\lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Q}}^0)\\[4pt] &= \lambda_{\text{G}}^0 - \lambda_{\text{Q}}^0. \end{aligned}$

Both sides are identical, hence option B is correct.

Option C claims

(Λm0)H2O  =  (Λm0)HCl+(Λm0)NaOH−(Λm0)NaCl.(\Lambda_m^0)_{H_2O} \;=\; (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{HCl}} + (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaOH}} - (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaCl}}.

Writing each conductivity in ionic form:

(Λm0)H2O=λH0+λOH0,(Λm0)HCl=λH0+λCl0,(Λm0)NaOH=λNa0+λOH0,(Λm0)NaCl=λNa0+λCl0.\begin{aligned} (\Lambda_m^0)_{H_2O} &= \lambda_{\text{H}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{OH}}^0,\\ (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{HCl}} &= \lambda_{\text{H}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0,\\ (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaOH}} &= \lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{OH}}^0,\\ (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaCl}} &= \lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0. \end{aligned}$

Substituting into the RHS:

RHS=(λH0+λCl0)+(λNa0+λOH0)−(λNa0+λCl0)=λH0+λOH0,\begin{aligned} \text{RHS} &= (\lambda_{\text{H}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0) + (\lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{OH}}^0) - (\lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Cl}}^0)\\[4pt] &= \lambda_{\text{H}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{OH}}^0, \end{aligned}$

which matches the LHS exactly. Therefore option C is correct.

Option D proposes

(Λm0)NaBr−(Λm0)NaI  =  (Λm0)KBr−(Λm0)KI.(\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaBr}} - (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{NaI}} \;=\; (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{KBr}} - (\Lambda_m^0)_{\text{KI}}.

Again convert to ionic contributions:

LHS=(λNa0+λBr0)−(λNa0+λI0)=λBr0−λI0,RHS=(λK0+λBr0)−(λK0+λI0)=λBr0−λI0.\begin{aligned} \text{LHS} &= (\lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Br}}^0) - (\lambda_{\text{Na}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{I}}^0)\\[4pt] &= \lambda_{\text{Br}}^0 - \lambda_{\text{I}}^0,\\[8pt] \text{RHS} &= (\lambda_{\text{K}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{Br}}^0) - (\lambda_{\text{K}}^0 + \lambda_{\text{I}}^0)\\[4pt] &= \lambda_{\text{Br}}^0 - \lambda_{\text{I}}^0. \end{aligned}$

Both sides coincide, so option D is correct.

From these detailed algebraic checks we see that only option A fails the equality test.

Hence, the answer is Option A.

Tagged Conductance, conductivity and molar conductivity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicConductance, conductivity and molar conductivity
TypeMultiple choice