JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Electrode potentials, electrochemical series and cell EMF
For the given cell; Cu(s)∣Cu2+(C1M)∣∣Cu2+(C2M)∣Cu(s) change in Gibbs energy (ΔG) is negative, it:
SOLUTION
We start by examining the given cell notation Cu(s)∣Cu2+(C1M)∣∣Cu2+(C2M)∣Cu(s)$ carefully. In the conventional cell diagram the species written on the left form the anode (oxidation takes place), while those on the right form the cathode (reduction takes place).
Thus, at the anode we have the oxidation half-reaction
Cu(s)⟶Cu2+(C1)+2e−
and at the cathode the reduction half-reaction
Cu2+(C2)+2e−⟶Cu(s).
Adding the two half-reactions gives the overall cell reaction
Cu2+(C2)⟶Cu2+(C1).
Notice that solid copper cancels out and only the two ionic concentrations appear. For such a concentration cell the standard e.m.f. is zero, Ecell∘=0, because both electrodes are made of the same material.
Now we invoke the Nernst equation. First we state it in its general form:
E=Ecell∘−n0.0591logQat T=298 K,
where Q is the reaction quotient and n is the number of electrons transferred.
Here, n=2 (two electrons in each half-reaction). The reaction quotient for the overall reaction
Cu2+(C2)⟶Cu2+(C1)
is simply
Q=[Cu2+]reactants[Cu2+]products=C2C1.
Substituting Ecell∘=0, n=2 and Q=C2C1 in the Nernst equation, we obtain
E=0−20.0591log(C2C1)=20.0591log(C1C2).
Next we relate the e.m.f. to the change in Gibbs free energy. We state the equation first:
ΔG=−nFE,
where F is the Faraday constant. The quantity F is always positive, and n=2 is also positive, so the sign of ΔG is completely determined by the sign of E.
For the process to be spontaneous we require ΔG<0, which demands E>0.
From the expression
E=20.0591log(C1C2),
we see that E>0 if and only if the logarithm is positive, i.e.
log(C1C2)>0⟹C1C2>1⟹C2>C1.
Therefore the concentration on the cathode side must exceed that on the anode side for the cell to run spontaneously (giving negative ΔG).
Examining the four options:
A. C1=C2 gives C2/C1=1 and hence E=0→ not spontaneous.
B. C2=2C1 gives C2/C1<1→E<0→ not spontaneous.
C. C1=2C2 also yields C2/C1<1→E<0.
D. C2=2C1 gives C1C2=2>1, so
E=20.0591log(2)>0⇒ΔG<0.
Only Option D satisfies the requirement ΔG<0.
Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.
Tagged Electrode potentials, electrochemical series and cell EMF. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.