We begin by noting the given standard reduction potentials at 298 K:
MnO4−+8H++5e−→Mn2++4H2O,E∘=1.51V
Cl2+2e−→2Cl−,E∘=1.36V
Br2+2e−→2Br−,E∘=1.07V
I2+2e−→2I−,E∘=0.54V
The permanganate reaction involves protons, so its potential changes with pH. The Nernst equation for any redox half-reaction is first stated:
E=E∘−n0.059logQ,
where n is the number of electrons and Q is the reaction quotient. For the permanganate half-reaction we have n=5 and
Q=[MnO4−][H+]8[Mn2+].
We take the standard state concentrations for Mn2+ and MnO4− as 1M, so Q=1/[H+]8. Substituting this into the Nernst equation gives
E=1.51−50.059log([H+]81).
Because log([H+]81)=−log[H+]8=−8log[H+]=8pH, we obtain
E=1.51−50.059(8pH).
At the specified pH of 3 we set pH=3:
E=1.51−50.059(8×3).
Evaluate the coefficient first:
50.059=0.0118.
Now multiply by 8×3=24:
0.0118×24=0.2832.
Finally, subtract this from the standard potential:
E=1.51−0.2832=1.2268 V≈1.23 V.
This is the actual reduction potential of MnO4− to Mn2+ at pH 3.
Next we compare this value with the standard (pH-independent) reduction potentials of the halogen couples:
EMnO4−/Mn2+(pH=3)=1.23V,
ECl2/Cl−∘=1.36V,
EBr2/Br−∘=1.07V,
EI2/I−∘=0.54V.
If the permanganate potential is greater than the halogen potential, it can oxidize the corresponding halide ion. We therefore compare:
For chloride: 1.23V<1.36V ⇒ permanganate is weaker than needed ⇒ no oxidation of Cl−.
For bromide: 1.23V>1.07V ⇒ permanganate is strong enough ⇒ Br− will be oxidized to Br2.
For iodide: 1.23V>0.54V ⇒ permanganate is also strong enough ⇒ I− will be oxidized to I2.
Thus, at pH 3, permanganate can oxidize bromide and iodide ions, but not chloride.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.