RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 APR S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Conductance, conductivity and molar conductivity

Consider the statements S1 and S2:
S1: Conductivity always increases with decreases in the concentration of electrolyte.
S2: Molar conductivity always increases with decreases in the concentration of electrolyte.
The correct option among the following

SOLUTION

We start by recalling the definitions that link the electrical properties of an electrolyte solution with its concentration.

First, the electrical conductivity (also called specific conductance) is denoted by κ\kappa and is defined as the conductance of a solution placed between two opposite faces of a (hypothetical) cube of length 1 cm1\ \text{cm}. Mathematically, its fundamental relation with resistivity ρ\rho is

κ  =  1ρ.\kappa \;=\;\dfrac{1}{\rho}.

For an electrolyte solution, κ\kappa is directly proportional to the actual number of ions present in a unit volume. If we denote the amount‐of‐substance concentration by c  (mol L−1)c\;(\text{mol L}^{-1}), then—keeping temperature fixed—we can write

κ  ∝  c.\kappa\;\propto\;c.

In simple words, as concentration decreases, the number of ions per unit volume decreases, and therefore κ\kappa also decreases. There is no point beyond which κ\kappa spontaneously starts increasing; the trend is monotonic.

Second, the molar conductivity of the same solution is denoted by Λm\Lambda_m and is defined by the formula

Λm  =  κ  1000c,\Lambda_m \;=\;\dfrac{\kappa\;1000}{c},

where the factor 10001000 merely converts litres to cubic centimetres (because κ\kappa is measured with distances in centimetres). This definition means that Λm\Lambda_m represents the conductance of all the ions produced by one mole of the electrolyte when they are placed between the same two electrodes 1 cm1\ \text{cm} apart.

Now observe the algebraic relationship carefully. If we substitute the proportionality κ∝c\kappa \propto c into the definition of Λm\Lambda_m, we get

Λm  =  κ  1000c  ∝  cc  =  1.\Lambda_m \;=\;\dfrac{\kappa\;1000}{c}\;\propto\;\dfrac{c}{c}\;=\;1.

However, this proportionality misses an important physical detail: although κ\kappa indeed falls linearly with decreasing cc in very dilute ranges, the factor 1/c1/c multiplies the conductivity. Consequently, the net result is that molar conductivity increases as concentration decreases. At the limit c→0c\to 0 (infinite dilution) we reach the maximum attainable molar conductivity Λm∘\Lambda_m^\circ.

Putting both results together:

• Specific conductivity κ\kappa decreases with decreasing concentration.
• Molar conductivity Λm\Lambda_m increases with decreasing concentration.

Examine the given statements:

S1: “Conductivity always increases with decrease in the concentration of electrolyte.” This is the opposite of what we have just deduced, so S1 is wrong.

S2: “Molar conductivity always increases with decrease in the concentration of electrolyte.” This matches our conclusion exactly, so S2 is correct.

Only the option that declares S1 wrong and S2 correct fits the analysis, and that option is Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Conductance, conductivity and molar conductivity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicConductance, conductivity and molar conductivity
TypeMultiple choice