Given below are two statements: Statement I : The higher oxidation states are more stable down the group among transition elements unlike p-block elements. Statement II : Copper can not liberate hydrogen from weak acids. In the light of the above statements, choose the correct answer from the options given below :
We need to evaluate the truth of two statements about transition elements.
Statement I: "The higher oxidation states are more stable down the group among transition elements unlike p-block elements."
This statement is true. Here is why:
In transition elements, as we go down a group, the higher oxidation states become increasingly stable. This is because:
- The ionisation enthalpies of 4d and 5d elements are comparable (and sometimes lower than expected) due to poor shielding by intervening electron shells.
- The greater spatial extension of 4d and 5d orbitals compared to 3d orbitals allows better orbital overlap, which stabilises higher oxidation states through stronger bonding.
- For example, in Group 6: Cr commonly shows +3 and +6, but Mo and W preferentially show +6. In Group 8: Fe shows +2 and +3, while Os readily shows +8 (as in ).
This is opposite to p-block elements, where the lower oxidation states become more stable down the group due to the inert pair effect.
Statement II: "Copper cannot liberate hydrogen from weak acids."
This statement is true. Here is why:
The ability of a metal to liberate hydrogen from acids depends on its standard electrode potential. A metal can liberate only if its standard reduction potential is less than that of the couple ( V).
Copper has a positive standard reduction potential: V.
Since , copper is a less reactive (more noble) metal than hydrogen. Therefore, copper cannot reduce ions to gas, even from dilute strong acids, let alone from weak acids (which have even lower concentration). The reaction is thermodynamically unfavourable (positive ).
Since both statements are true, the correct answer is Option 1: Both Statement I and Statement II are true.
Tagged General properties of transition elements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.