We have to check whether the given divalent transition-metal ions can act as reducing agents strong enough to convert hydrogen ions from a dilute acid into molecular hydrogen. In other words, we must test whether the reaction
M2++2H+→M3++H2
is spontaneous for each ion. Spontaneity is decided with standard electrode (reduction) potentials. First, recall the definition:
For any redox couple Ox+ne−→Red the standard reduction potential is denoted E∘. If two half-reactions are combined so that
cell reaction=reduction half-reaction+oxidation half-reaction,
then the overall standard cell potential is
Ecell∘=Ered∘(reduction)−Ered∘(oxidation).
If Ecell∘>0, the reaction is spontaneous in the forward direction.
In the present case the reduction half-reaction is the hydrogen electrode:
2H++2e−→H2,Ered∘=0.00V.
The oxidation half-reaction is simply the reverse of the M3+/M2+ reduction couple:
M2+→M3++e−.
Hence, for each ion,
Ecell∘=0.00V−Ered∘(M3+/M2+).
The requirement Ecell∘>0 simplifies to
0.00V−Ered∘(M3+/M2+)>0⟹Ered∘(M3+/M2+)<0.00V.
So, only those M2+ ions whose M3+/M2+ reduction potential is negative will be able to displace hydrogen from dilute acids.
Now we list the standard reduction potentials (all values at 298 K, 1 M):
Ti3++e−V3++e−Cr3++e−Mn3++e−→Ti2+,→V2+,→Cr2+,→Mn2+,E∘E∘E∘E∘=−0.37V,=−0.26V,=−0.41V,=+1.51V.
We see that
- E∘(Ti3+/Ti2+)=−0.37V<0, so Ti2+ will reduce H+ to H2.
- E∘(V3+/V2+)=−0.26V<0, so V2+ will also liberate H2.$
- E∘(Cr3+/Cr2+)=−0.41V<0, so Cr2+ likewise produces H2.$
- E∘(Mn3+/Mn2+)=+1.51V which is positive. Substituting into the earlier expression gives
Ecell∘=0.00V−(+1.51V)=−1.51V<0.
The negative value means the forward reaction is non-spontaneous; therefore Mn2+ cannot reduce H+, and no hydrogen gas is evolved.
Hence, among the given options, only Mn2+ fails to liberate hydrogen gas with dilute acids.
Hence, the correct answer is Option C.