RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — General properties of transition elements

Which of the following ions does not liberate hydrogen gas on reaction with dilute acids?

SOLUTION

We have to check whether the given divalent transition-metal ions can act as reducing agents strong enough to convert hydrogen ions from a dilute acid into molecular hydrogen. In other words, we must test whether the reaction

M2+  +  2 H+  →  M3+  +  H2M^{2+}\;+\;2\,H^+\;\rightarrow\;M^{3+}\;+\;H_2

is spontaneous for each ion. Spontaneity is decided with standard electrode (reduction) potentials. First, recall the definition:

For any redox couple Ox+ne−→RedOx + ne^- \rightarrow Red the standard reduction potential is denoted E∘E^\circ. If two half-reactions are combined so that

cell reaction  =  reduction half-reaction  +  oxidation half-reaction,\text{cell reaction}\;=\;\text{reduction half-reaction}\;+\;\text{oxidation half-reaction},

then the overall standard cell potential is

Ecell∘=Ered∘(reduction)−Ered∘(oxidation).E^\circ_{cell}=E^\circ_{\text{red}}(\text{reduction})-E^\circ_{\text{red}}(\text{oxidation}).

If Ecell∘>0,E^\circ_{cell}\gt 0, the reaction is spontaneous in the forward direction.

In the present case the reduction half-reaction is the hydrogen electrode:

2 H++2e−  →  H2,Ered∘=0.00  V.2\,H^+ + 2e^- \;\rightarrow\; H_2,\qquad E^\circ_{\text{red}}=0.00\;{\rm V}.

The oxidation half-reaction is simply the reverse of the M3+/M2+M^{3+}/M^{2+} reduction couple:

M2+  →  M3++e−.M^{2+}\;\rightarrow\;M^{3+}+e^-.

Hence, for each ion,

Ecell∘=0.00  V−Ered∘(M3+/M2+).E^\circ_{cell}=0.00\;{\rm V}-E^\circ_{\text{red}}(M^{3+}/M^{2+}).

The requirement Ecell∘>0E^\circ_{cell}\gt 0 simplifies to

0.00  V−Ered∘(M3+/M2+)>0    ⟹    Ered∘(M3+/M2+)<0.00  V.0.00\;{\rm V}-E^\circ_{\text{red}}(M^{3+}/M^{2+})\gt 0\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;E^\circ_{\text{red}}(M^{3+}/M^{2+})\lt 0.00\;{\rm V}.

So, only those M2+M^{2+} ions whose M3+/M2+M^{3+}/M^{2+} reduction potential is negative will be able to displace hydrogen from dilute acids.

Now we list the standard reduction potentials (all values at 298 K, 1 M):

Ti3++e−→Ti2+,E∘=−0.37  V,V3++e−→V2+,  E∘=−0.26  V,Cr3++e−→Cr2+,E∘=−0.41  V,Mn3++e−→Mn2+,  E∘=+1.51  V.\begin{aligned} Ti^{3+}+e^- &\rightarrow Ti^{2+}, & E^\circ &= -0.37\;{\rm V},\\[2pt] V^{3+}+e^- &\rightarrow V^{2+},\; & E^\circ &= -0.26\;{\rm V},\\[2pt] Cr^{3+}+e^- &\rightarrow Cr^{2+}, & E^\circ &= -0.41\;{\rm V},\\[2pt] Mn^{3+}+e^- &\rightarrow Mn^{2+},\; & E^\circ &= +1.51\;{\rm V}. \end{aligned}

We see that

  • E∘(Ti3+/Ti2+)=−0.37  V<0,E^\circ(Ti^{3+}/Ti^{2+})=-0.37\;{\rm V}\lt 0, so Ti2+Ti^{2+} will reduce H+H^+ to H2.H_2.
  • E∘(V3+/V2+)=−0.26  V<0,E^\circ(V^{3+}/V^{2+})=-0.26\;{\rm V}\lt 0, so V2+V^{2+} will also liberate H2.H_2.$
  • E∘(Cr3+/Cr2+)=−0.41  V<0,E^\circ(Cr^{3+}/Cr^{2+})=-0.41\;{\rm V}\lt 0, so Cr2+Cr^{2+} likewise produces H2.H_2.$
  • E∘(Mn3+/Mn2+)=+1.51  VE^\circ(Mn^{3+}/Mn^{2+})=+1.51\;{\rm V} which is positive. Substituting into the earlier expression gives

    Ecell∘=0.00  V−(+1.51  V)=−1.51  V<0.E^\circ_{cell}=0.00\;{\rm V}-(+1.51\;{\rm V})=-1.51\;{\rm V}\lt 0.

    The negative value means the forward reaction is non-spontaneous; therefore Mn2+Mn^{2+} cannot reduce H+H^+, and no hydrogen gas is evolved.

Hence, among the given options, only Mn2+Mn^{2+} fails to liberate hydrogen gas with dilute acids.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged General properties of transition elements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeneral properties of transition elements
TypeMultiple choice