Which one of the following species is stable in aqueous solution?
We have to find which ion or oxo-anion can remain as it is when it is put into ordinary water. In aqueous medium an ion will be called “stable” only when it does not undergo self-oxidation, self-reduction or any other spontaneous redox change such as disproportionation.
The simplest way to judge this behaviour is to compare the standard electrode potentials of the redox couples that involve the given species. We recall the general principle:
then the intermediate oxidation state will undergo disproportionation because the reduction to the lower state is easier than its own re-oxidation back to the higher state.
Now we examine each option one by one.
Option A :
The standard potentials for chromium are
Because both potentials are highly negative, is a very strong reducing agent. In water it is readily oxidised by dissolved oxygen to the more stable state. Hence is not stable in aqueous solution.
Option B :
For the manganate series the relevant redox couples are
Here we notice two points:
(i) The first reduction potential is not so large that water will automatically reduce to , but it is large enough to keep from getting oxidised back by dissolved oxygen.
(ii) The second potential is smaller; therefore does not have a strong tendency to get further reduced to in neutral water.
Consequently persists in alkaline or even mildly neutral medium as a green manganate solution. Thus it is reasonably stable in water.
Option C :
The step that could destroy this ion is
Because the potential for is extremely small (in fact negative when calculated), the ion is an exceedingly powerful reducing agent. It instantly reacts with even the solvent water and disproportionates. Hence is not stable in aqueous solution.
Option D :
The copper redox data are
To test disproportionation of we write the composite reaction
For this overall process the net potential is
Since is positive, the reaction is spontaneous, so disproportionates in water to metal and ion. Therefore is definitely not stable.
Summarising all four cases we find that only resists any spontaneous redox change in aqueous solution.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged General properties of transition elements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.