RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Chemistry question — General properties of transition elements

Which one of the following species is stable in aqueous solution?

SOLUTION

We have to find which ion or oxo-anion can remain as it is when it is put into ordinary water. In aqueous medium an ion will be called “stable” only when it does not undergo self-oxidation, self-reduction or any other spontaneous redox change such as disproportionation.

The simplest way to judge this behaviour is to compare the standard electrode potentials E∘E^\circ of the redox couples that involve the given species. We recall the general principle:

If E∘(oxidation step)<E∘(reduction step),\text{If }E^\circ(\text{oxidation step})\lt E^\circ(\text{reduction step}), then the intermediate oxidation state will undergo disproportionation because the reduction to the lower state is easier than its own re-oxidation back to the higher state.

Now we examine each option one by one.

Option A : Cr2+Cr^{2+}

The standard potentials for chromium are

Cr3++e−→Cr2+,  E∘=−0.41  VCr^{3+}+e^- \rightarrow Cr^{2+},\;E^\circ=-0.41\;{\rm V} Cr2++2e−→Cr,  E∘=−0.91  VCr^{2+}+2e^- \rightarrow Cr,\;E^\circ=-0.91\;{\rm V}

Because both potentials are highly negative, Cr2+Cr^{2+} is a very strong reducing agent. In water it is readily oxidised by dissolved oxygen to the more stable Cr3+Cr^{3+} state. Hence Cr2+Cr^{2+} is not stable in aqueous solution.

Option B : MnO42−MnO_4^{2-}

For the manganate series the relevant redox couples are

MnO4−+e−→MnO42−,  E∘=+0.56  VMnO_4^- + e^- \rightarrow MnO_4^{2-},\;E^\circ=+0.56\;{\rm V} MnO42−+e−→MnO43−,  E∘=+0.37  VMnO_4^{2-} + e^- \rightarrow MnO_4^{3-},\;E^\circ=+0.37\;{\rm V}

Here we notice two points:

(i) The first reduction potential +0.56V+0.56{\rm V} is not so large that water will automatically reduce MnO4−MnO_4^- to MnO42−MnO_4^{2-}, but it is large enough to keep MnO42−MnO_4^{2-} from getting oxidised back by dissolved oxygen.

(ii) The second potential +0.37V+0.37{\rm V} is smaller; therefore MnO42−MnO_4^{2-} does not have a strong tendency to get further reduced to MnO43−MnO_4^{3-} in neutral water.

Consequently MnO42−MnO_4^{2-} persists in alkaline or even mildly neutral medium as a green manganate solution. Thus it is reasonably stable in water.

Option C : MnO43−MnO_4^{3-}

The step that could destroy this ion is

2 MnO43−→MnO42−+MnO44−2\,MnO_4^{3-} \rightarrow MnO_4^{2-} + MnO_4^{4-}

Because the potential for MnO43−+e−→MnO44−MnO_4^{3-} + e^- \rightarrow MnO_4^{4-} is extremely small (in fact negative when calculated), the ion is an exceedingly powerful reducing agent. It instantly reacts with even the solvent water and disproportionates. Hence MnO43−MnO_4^{3-} is not stable in aqueous solution.

Option D : Cu+Cu^+

The copper redox data are

Cu2++e−→Cu+,  E∘=+0.153  VCu^{2+}+e^- \rightarrow Cu^+,\;E^\circ=+0.153\;{\rm V} Cu++e−→Cu,  E∘=+0.521  VCu^++e^- \rightarrow Cu,\;E^\circ=+0.521\;{\rm V}

To test disproportionation of Cu+Cu^+ we write the composite reaction

2 Cu+→Cu2++Cu2\,Cu^+ \rightarrow Cu^{2+}+Cu

For this overall process the net potential is

E∘=Ered∘(Cu2+/Cu+)+Ered∘(Cu+/Cu)2=0.153  V+0.521  V2=0.337  V>0E^\circ = \dfrac{E^\circ_{\text{red}}(Cu^{2+}/Cu^+) + E^\circ_{\text{red}}(Cu^+/Cu)}{2} = \dfrac{0.153\;{\rm V} + 0.521\;{\rm V}}{2}=0.337\;{\rm V}>0

Since E∘E^\circ is positive, the reaction is spontaneous, so Cu+Cu^+ disproportionates in water to CuCu metal and Cu2+Cu^{2+} ion. Therefore Cu+Cu^+ is definitely not stable.

Summarising all four cases we find that only MnO42−MnO_4^{2-} resists any spontaneous redox change in aqueous solution.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged General properties of transition elements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeneral properties of transition elements
TypeMultiple choice