The lanthanide ion that would show colour is:
We recall the well-known fact for lanthanide (4f) ions: an ion displays colour in solution or in the solid state only when an electronic transition is possible within its 4f subshell. Such a transition is possible when the 4f subshell is partially but not exactly half-filled or completely filled. In three special cases the ion is practically colourless because no low-energy transition is available:
1. configuration (no 4f electrons)
2. configuration (exactly half-filled)
3. configuration (completely filled)
Now we write the electronic configurations of the given trivalent lanthanide ions. The neutral atoms follow the general sequence , and when three electrons are removed to give the oxidation state, the two 6s electrons and one 5d (if present) are lost first. Thus, for the ions we have:
La:
Gd:
Lu:
Sm:
We now compare each configuration with the three special colourless cases:
• has , falling directly under the first colourless category. So it is colourless.
• has , the exactly half-filled case. This belongs to the second colourless category. Hence it is colourless.
• has , the completely filled case. It matches the third colourless category and is therefore colourless.
• has , which is neither empty, nor exactly half-filled, nor completely filled. Therefore an transition of suitable energy is possible, and the ion appears coloured.
So only shows colour.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Lanthanoids and lanthanoid contraction. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.