RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2014 · 06 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2014 Chemistry question — General properties of transition elements

Which series of reactions correctly represents the chemical relations related to iron and its compound?

SOLUTION

First, we write down the four proposed sequences exactly as given so that we can examine each step:

Option A :   Fe  →  FeSO4  →  Fe2(SO4)3  →  FeFe \;\rightarrow\; FeSO_4 \;\rightarrow\; Fe_2(SO_4)_3 \;\rightarrow\; Fe

Option B :   Fe  →  FeO  →  FeSO4  →  FeFe \;\rightarrow\; FeO \;\rightarrow\; FeSO_4 \;\rightarrow\; Fe

Option C :   Fe  →  FeCl3  →  FeCl2  →  FeFe \;\rightarrow\; FeCl_3 \;\rightarrow\; FeCl_2 \;\rightarrow\; Fe

Option D :   Fe  →  Fe3O4  →  FeO  →  FeFe \;\rightarrow\; Fe_3O_4 \;\rightarrow\; FeO \;\rightarrow\; Fe

Now we test every step of every option against the well-known reactions of iron and its compounds.

In Option A the first step is the ordinary reaction of iron with dilute sulphuric acid:

Fe+H2SO4(dil.)  →  FeSO4+H2↑Fe + H_2SO_4(dil.) \;\rightarrow\; FeSO_4 + H_2\uparrow

That step is correct. The second step claims that ferrous sulphate is converted into ferric sulphate simply by adding more H2SO4H_2SO_4 and O2O_2. In reality, direct oxidation of FeSO4FeSO_4 in acid gives a mixture containing Fe2(SO4)3Fe_2(SO_4)_3, so this might still be acceptable. But the third step says that heating Fe2(SO4)3Fe_2(SO_4)_3 yields metallic iron:

Fe2(SO4)3  →heat  FeFe_2(SO_4)_3 \;\xrightarrow{\text{heat}}\; Fe

This is impossible. The correct thermal decomposition is

2 Fe2(SO4)3  →  2 Fe2O3+6 SO32\,Fe_2(SO_4)_3 \;\rightarrow\; 2\,Fe_2O_3 + 6\,SO_3

No free iron is produced, so Option A fails.

In Option B the first step proposes the formation of FeOFeO by simply heating iron in oxygen:

2 Fe+O2  →heat  2 FeO2\,Fe + O_2 \;\xrightarrow{\text{heat}}\; 2\,FeO

Actually, ordinary oxidation of iron in air gives a mixture dominated by Fe3O4Fe_3O_4, not pure FeOFeO. Hence even the first arrow is doubtful. Moreover, the last step claims that heating FeSO4FeSO_4 alone produces metallic iron:

FeSO4  →heat  FeFeSO_4 \;\xrightarrow{\text{heat}}\; Fe

The true decomposition is

2 FeSO4  →  Fe2O3+SO2+SO32\,FeSO_4 \;\rightarrow\; Fe_2O_3 + SO_2 + SO_3

Again no iron metal appears, so Option B is incorrect.

Option C starts correctly because iron combines with chlorine on heating to give ferric chloride:

2 Fe+3 Cl2  →heat  2 FeCl32\,Fe + 3\,Cl_2 \;\xrightarrow{\text{heat}}\; 2\,FeCl_3

The next step claims that further heating of FeCl3FeCl_3 in air converts it into FeCl2FeCl_2:

2 FeCl3  →heat, air  2 FeCl2+Cl22\,FeCl_3 \;\xrightarrow{\text{heat, air}}\; 2\,FeCl_2 + Cl_2

In reality, heating FeCl3FeCl_3 in air does not reduce it; instead it hydrolyses to give Fe2O3Fe_2O_3 with the liberation of HClHCl or Cl2Cl_2. Therefore the second arrow is wrong, so the whole chain cannot be correct even though the last displacement Zn+FeCl2→ZnCl2+FeZn + FeCl_2 \rightarrow ZnCl_2 + Fe would otherwise work.

Finally we analyse Option D. The first arrow describes the partial oxidation of iron on strong heating in oxygen:

3 Fe+2 O2  →heat  Fe3O43\,Fe + 2\,O_2 \;\xrightarrow{\text{heat}}\; Fe_3O_4

This is precisely what happens; the black oxide Fe3O4Fe_3O_4 (magnetite) is produced. Now we supply carbon monoxide at about 600 °C. The blast-furnace reduction of magnetite proceeds in two stages. At the lower temperature the reaction is

Fe3O4+CO  →600∘ ⁣C  3 FeO+CO2Fe_3O_4 + CO \;\xrightarrow{600^{\circ}\!C}\; 3\,FeO + CO_2

Thus the second arrow Fe3O4→FeOFe_3O_4 \rightarrow FeO with COCO as the reducing agent is fully justified. When the partly reduced ore (FeOFeO) meets hotter rising CO (≈700 °C or above) a further reduction occurs:

FeO+CO  →700∘ ⁣C  Fe+CO2FeO + CO \;\xrightarrow{700^{\circ}\!C}\; Fe + CO_2

So the final step FeO→FeFeO \rightarrow Fe is perfectly valid. Every arrow in Option D is therefore correct, and the overall sequence accurately reproduces the industrial route found in a blast furnace.

Since Options A, B and C each contain at least one impossible or incorrect transformation, while every step in Option D is chemically sound, Option D is the only correct choice.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged General properties of transition elements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeneral properties of transition elements
TypeMultiple choice