The incorrect statement is:
Let us examine each statement one by one, keeping in mind the electronic configurations of the ions that actually decide their magnetic behaviour.
The atomic number of manganese is , so in the ground state the electronic configuration of the neutral atom is
Statement A says that manganate and permanganate ions are tetrahedral. Both ions contain the central manganese atom surrounded by four oxygen atoms and the steric number is , giving a tetrahedral geometry. Hence Statement A is correct.
Statement B talks about -bonding. In these oxyanions, after the -framework is formed with hybrid orbitals on oxygen, the remaining unhybridised -orbitals of oxygen overlap sideways with empty or half-filled -orbitals of manganese, giving -bonding. Thus the statement is in accordance with molecular orbital considerations and is also correct.
Statement C claims that both manganate and permanganate ions are paramagnetic. To verify this we must calculate the number of -electrons present in each oxidation state.
1. For the manganate ion, , the oxidation state of manganese is found by writing
So manganese is in the state. We remove six electrons from the neutral atom:
First electrons come out of the orbital and the next from the orbitals:
Thus, in we have , i.e. one unpaired electron, so the ion is paramagnetic.
2. For the permanganate ion, , the oxidation state is
Now seven electrons are removed from the neutral atom:
The subshell is now empty, so no unpaired electrons are present; hence is diamagnetic.
Therefore, although the manganate ion is paramagnetic, the permanganate ion is diamagnetic. The assertion that both ions are paramagnetic is false.
Statement D saying that the manganate ion is green and the permanganate ion is purple is a well-known experimental fact from qualitative inorganic analysis, so it is correct.
Only Statement C is incorrect.
Hence, the correct answer is Option C.
Tagged Other important compounds of transition metals. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.