RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2009TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2009 Chemistry question — General properties of transition elements

In context with the transition elements, which of the following statements is incorrect?

SOLUTION

The question asks us to find the incorrect statement about transition (d-block) elements. We shall examine every option one by one.

Option A: “In addition to the normal oxidation states, the zero oxidation state is also shown by these elements in complexes.”
• Many transition metals form neutral (zero-oxidation-state) carbonyls and related complexes, e.g. Ni(CO)4Ni(CO)_4, Fe(CO)5Fe(CO)_5, Cr(CO)6Cr(CO)_6, V(CO)6V(CO)_6.
• Hence a zero oxidation state is indeed possible for several transition metals.
Therefore, Option A is a correct statement.

Option B: “In the highest oxidation states, the transition metal show basic character and form cationic complexes.”
• At very high oxidation states the metal centre possesses a high positive charge density. This makes the species strongly electrophilic (acidic), not basic.
• Such metals commonly form oxo-anions and covalent oxides, e.g. MnO4−MnO_4^- (Mn in +7), Cr2O72−Cr_2O_7^{2-} (Cr in +6), VO3−VO_3^- (V in +5). These are anionic or neutral covalent species, not cationic complexes.
Therefore, Option B is an incorrect statement.

Option C: “In the highest oxidation states of the first five transition elements (Sc to Mn), all the 4s4s and 3d3d electrons are used for bonding.”
Sc: [Ar] 3d14s2→+3[Ar]\,3d^1 4s^2 \rightarrow +3 (uses 3 electrons)
Ti: [Ar] 3d24s2→+4[Ar]\,3d^2 4s^2 \rightarrow +4 (4 electrons)
V: [Ar] 3d34s2→+5[Ar]\,3d^3 4s^2 \rightarrow +5 (5 electrons)
Cr: [Ar] 3d54s1→+6[Ar]\,3d^5 4s^1 \rightarrow +6 (6 electrons)
Mn: [Ar] 3d54s2→+7[Ar]\,3d^5 4s^2 \rightarrow +7 (7 electrons)
• In every case the sum of all 4s4s and 3d3d electrons equals the group number and is employed in the maximum oxidation state. Hence the statement is true.
Therefore, Option C is a correct statement.

Option D: “Once the d5d^5 configuration is exceeded, the tendency to involve all the 3d electrons in bonding decreases.”
• Beyond Mn (which is d5d^5), the maximum attainable oxidation states begin to drop: Fe+6Fe^{+6} (rare), Co+5Co^{+5} (rare), Ni+4Ni^{+4}, Cu+3Cu^{+3}, Zn+2Zn^{+2}. Thus, metals with more than five d electrons usually do not utilise all of them in bonding.
Therefore, Option D is a correct statement.

Only Option B conflicts with the well-established behaviour of transition metals in high oxidation states. Hence the incorrect statement is:

Option B which is: In the highest oxidation states, the transition metal show basic character and form cationic complexes.

Tagged General properties of transition elements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeneral properties of transition elements
TypeMultiple choice