RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2009TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2009 Chemistry question — Lanthanoids and lanthanoid contraction

Knowing that the Chemistry of lanthanoids (Ln) is dominated by its +3+3 oxidation state, which of the following statements in incorrect?

SOLUTION

The chemistry of lanthanoids is indeed dominated by the +3+3 oxidation state, so we must judge each statement for Ln3+\mathrm{Ln^{3+}} compounds.

Case A: “Because of the large size of the Ln3+\mathrm{Ln^{3+}} ions the bonding in its compounds is predominantly ionic in character.”
Ln3+\mathrm{Ln^{3+}} ions possess large radii (≈ 1.06 1.06\,\r{A} for La3+^{3+} to 0.85 0.85\,\r{A} for Lu3+^{3+}). Large, highly electropositive cations form compounds where electrostatic forces dominate, giving mostly ionic lattices. Hence statement A is correct.

Case B: “The ionic sizes of Ln3+\mathrm{Ln^{3+}} decrease in general with increasing atomic number.”
Across the lanthanoid series, ineffective shielding by 4f electrons leads to a steady increase in nuclear charge felt by the outer electrons. This “lanthanoid contraction’’ makes the ionic radius drop almost smoothly from La3+^{3+} to Lu3+^{3+}. Therefore statement B is correct.

Case C: “Ln3+\mathrm{Ln^{3+}} compounds are generally colourless.”
Most Ln3+\mathrm{Ln^{3+}} ions possess partially filled 4f subshells (e.g., Ce3+^{3+}: 4f1^{1}, Pr3+^{3+}: 4f2^{2}, …, Tm3+^{3+}: 4f12^{12}). Colours arise from parity-forbidden but vibronically allowed 4f → 4f electronic transitions. Only ions with 4f0^{0} (La3+^{3+}) or 4f14^{14} (Lu3+^{3+}, Yb2+^{2+}) are colourless; the majority show characteristic pastel shades (pink, yellow, green, etc.). Hence the generalisation that Ln(III) compounds are colourless is wrong. Statement C is incorrect.

Case D: “Ln(OH)3\mathrm{Ln(OH)_3} are mainly basic in character.”
Large Ln3+\mathrm{Ln^{3+}} ions hold hydroxide ions weakly, enabling OH−\mathrm{OH^-} to accept protons readily, so the hydroxides act as bases. Across the series basicity decreases because of lanthanoid contraction (charge density rises), yet they all remain predominantly basic. Statement D is correct.

Only statement C contradicts accepted lanthanoid chemistry.

Option C which is: Ln (III) compounds are generally colourless.

Tagged Lanthanoids and lanthanoid contraction. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicLanthanoids and lanthanoid contraction
TypeMultiple choice