RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Chemistry question — General properties of transition elements

Which of the following are the transition metal ions responsible for colour in ruby and emerald respectively?

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling a basic fact from crystal field theory: the brilliant colours seen in many gemstones originate from the presence of trace amounts of certain transition-metal ions. These ions replace some of the normal lattice cations, and their partly filled dd-orbitals split into energy sub-levels inside the crystal field created by the surrounding anions. When visible light falls on the crystal, specific wavelengths are absorbed to promote electrons from lower to higher dd-levels; the remaining transmitted or reflected light then appears to us as a characteristic colour.

First, let us examine ruby. Ruby is chemically a variety of corundum, whose ideal formula is Al2O3Al_2O_3. Inside the corundum lattice we normally have Al3+Al^{3+} ions. A very small fraction of these Al3+Al^{3+} ions are replaced (substituted) by another trivalent transition-metal ion. Experimental spectroscopy and crystal chemistry confirm that the ion doing this job is Cr3+Cr^{3+}. The presence of Cr3+Cr^{3+} introduces new energy levels inside the forbidden gap; electronic transitions between split dd-levels of Cr3+Cr^{3+} absorb green and violet light, so the transmitted light appears deep red. Hence, the red colour of ruby is due to Cr3+Cr^{3+} ions.

Now we turn to emerald. Emerald is a green variety of the mineral beryl, whose ideal formula is Be3Al2Si6O18Be_3Al_2Si_6O_{18}. Inside the beryl lattice we again have octahedrally coordinated Al3+Al^{3+} sites. Just as in corundum, some of these Al3+Al^{3+} sites are occupied by traces of Cr3+Cr^{3+} (sometimes accompanied by V3+V^{3+}). The Cr3+Cr^{3+} ion has a 3d33d^3 electronic configuration; under the octahedral field of surrounding oxygen ligands its dd-orbitals split into the usual t2gt_{2g} and ege_g sets. The energy gap between these sets happens to correspond to the absorption of red and blue light, so the complementary colour, rich green, is observed. Thus, the green colour of emerald is also produced by Cr3+Cr^{3+} ions.

Therefore, both in ruby and in emerald the transition-metal ion responsible for colour is the same, namely Cr3+Cr^{3+}. We match this inference with the alternatives given:

Option A: Co3+Co^{3+} and Cr3+Cr^{3+} - incorrect, ruby is not coloured by Co3+Co^{3+}.
Option B: Co3+Co^{3+} and Co3+Co^{3+} - incorrect for both gemstones.
Option C: Cr3+Cr^{3+} and Cr3+Cr^{3+} - correct for both ruby and emerald.
Option D: Cr3+Cr^{3+} and Ag+Ag^+ - incorrect, emerald is not coloured by Ag+Ag^+.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged General properties of transition elements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeneral properties of transition elements
TypeMultiple choice