RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — Werner's theory and coordination terminology

[Co2_2(CO)8_8] displays

SOLUTION

We first recall the 18-electron rule, which states that a stable, low-spin complex of a transition metal usually adjusts its bonding so that each metal centre possesses a total of 1818 valence electrons. The electrons come from the metal itself, from σ-donor ligands such as carbonyls (COCO) and, when present, from metal-metal (M−MM{-}M) bonds. For counting purposes:

• A neutral cobalt atom contributes its nine valence electrons, so CoCo gives 99 electrons.

• Every terminal COCO ligand donates a pair of electrons to the metal to which it is attached, so each terminal COCO contributes 22 electrons to that metal.

• A bridging COCO is shared between two metals. It donates one electron to each metal centre, giving a total of 22 electrons, one to each cobalt.

• A single metal-metal bond (Co−CoCo{-}Co) contributes one electron to each of the two bonded metals (two electrons in all).

With these points in mind, let us evaluate the electron count for every structural description offered in the options.

Option A No Co−CoCo{-}Co bond, six terminal COCO and two bridging COCO. For each cobalt we have:

Electrons=9  (from Co)+6×2  (from 6 terminal CO)+2×1  (from 2 bridging CO)=9+12+2=23\begin{aligned} \text{Electrons} &= 9 \;(\text{from } Co) + 6\times2 \;(\text{from 6 terminal } CO) + 2\times1 \;(\text{from 2 bridging } CO) \\ &= 9 + 12 + 2 = 23 \end{aligned}

Twenty-three electrons far exceed the 18-electron limit, so such a formulation is impossible. Hence Option A is rejected.

Option B No Co−CoCo{-}Co bond, four terminal COCO and four bridging COCO. Now each cobalt receives

Electrons=9  (from Co)+4×2  (from 4 terminal CO)+4×1  (from 4 bridging CO)=9+8+4=21\begin{aligned} \text{Electrons} &= 9 \;(\text{from } Co) + 4\times2 \;(\text{from 4 terminal } CO) + 4\times1 \;(\text{from 4 bridging } CO) \\ &= 9 + 8 + 4 = 21 \end{aligned}

Again the total is greater than 18, so Option B is also impossible.

Option C One Co−CoCo{-}Co bond, six terminal COCO and two bridging COCO. Here each cobalt counts

Electrons=9  (from Co)+6×2  (from 6 terminal CO)+2×1  (from 2 bridging CO)+1  (from the Co−Co bond)=9+12+2+1=24\begin{aligned} \text{Electrons} &= 9 \;(\text{from } Co) + 6\times2 \;(\text{from 6 terminal } CO) + 2\times1 \;(\text{from 2 bridging } CO) + 1 \;(\text{from the } Co{-}Co \text{ bond})\\ &= 9 + 12 + 2 + 1 = 24 \end{aligned}

The total again exceeds 18, so at first glance this appears unfavourable. However, we must notice that six terminal COCO and two bridging COCO together already constitute all eight carbonyl ligands in the formula [Co2(CO)8][Co_2(CO)_8]. A closer look shows that the count of terminal COCO ligands per cobalt is actually three, not six: each terminal COCO is attached to only one metal centre. Let us correct the calculation.

Per cobalt in Option C we really have:

Terminal CO:3(because 6 terminal CO shared equally)Bridging CO:2Electrons=9+3×2+2×1+1=9+6+2+1=18\begin{aligned} \text{Terminal } CO &: 3 \quad (\text{because 6 terminal CO shared equally})\\ \text{Bridging } CO &: 2\\[4pt] \text{Electrons} &= 9 + 3\times2 + 2\times1 + 1 \\ &= 9 + 6 + 2 + 1 = 18 \end{aligned}

Now the 18-electron requirement is exactly satisfied, so this structure is perfectly reasonable.

Option D One Co−CoCo{-}Co bond, four terminal COCO and four bridging COCO. Each cobalt then has:

Electrons=9+2×2  (because 4 terminal shared equally)+4×1+1=9+4+4+1=18\begin{aligned} \text{Electrons} &= 9 + 2\times2 \;(\text{because 4 terminal shared equally}) + 4\times1 + 1 \\ &= 9 + 4 + 4 + 1 = 18 \end{aligned}

This option also meets the 18-electron rule, so we need an additional criterion to differentiate Options C and D. Experimental crystallographic data resolve the matter: solid [Co2(CO)8][Co_2(CO)_8] indeed contains a single Co−CoCo{-}Co bond, with six terminal and two μ<sub>2</sub>-bridging carbonyl ligands. Only two carbonyls bridge the two cobalt atoms; the remaining six are terminal.

Therefore the observed structure matches Option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Werner's theory and coordination terminology. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicWerner's theory and coordination terminology
TypeMultiple choice