Identify the correct trend given below:
(Atomic No. = Ti : 22, Cr : 24 and Mo : 42)
We have to compare the octahedral crystal-field splitting parameter, written as (usually shown simply as ), for three pairs of complexes that carry the same ligand . Remember that is a weak-field ligand and therefore all the differences we are going to discuss come only from the metal centre and its oxidation state.
First we recall two general rules of crystal-field theory.
Rule 1 (same period, different oxidation state) — For a given metal ion and a given ligand, a higher oxidation state produces a larger splitting. Symbolically
This happens because the higher positive charge pulls the d-electrons closer, allowing the ligand field to interact more strongly with them.
Rule 2 (same group, going down the group) — For the same oxidation state and the same ligand, and metals experience a larger splitting than their congeners:
The underlying reason is that the more diffuse and orbitals overlap better with the ligand orbitals, strengthening the ligand field.
Now we apply these rules to the complexes given in the question.
Comparison 1: versus
Both ions are in the +2 oxidation state, so Rule 1 does not favour either. Chromium is a element (period 4) whereas molybdenum is a element (period 5). By Rule 2 we therefore have
So the inequality is
Comparison 2: versus
Here the metal is the same (titanium, a element), and the ligand is the same, so Rule 2 is irrelevant. Instead we invoke Rule 1. The +3 ion has a larger positive charge than the +2 ion, so we expect a larger splitting for the +3 species:
Putting both pieces together
From (3) we need the symbol < between the chromium(II) and molybdenum(II) complexes, and from (4) we need the symbol > between the titanium(III) and titanium(II) complexes. Scanning the four options, only Option C contains both these inequalities in exactly this order.
Hence, the correct answer is Option 3.
Tagged Colour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.