RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Chemistry question — Valence bond theory of complexes

Which one of the following complexes will consume more equivalents of aqueous solution of AgNO3AgNO_3?

SOLUTION

Our aim is to find, for every given salt, how many chloride ions lie outside the coordination sphere, because only those free chloride ions will react with an aqueous solution of AgNO3AgNO_3 to give a precipitate of AgClAgCl. One mole of such chloride needs one equivalent of AgNO3AgNO_3, so the salt that gives the greatest number of outside chloride ions will consume the largest number of equivalents of AgNO3AgNO_3.

We recall the charge-balance idea: in a neutral salt, the algebraic sum of the charges of the coordination entity and of the counter-ions must be zero.

Now we study every option one by one, carefully writing the charge equations.

Option A : Na2[CrCl5(H2O)]Na_2[CrCl_5(H_2O)]

Let the oxidation state of chromium be xx.

Inside the coordination sphere we have five Cl−Cl^- ligands and one neutral H2OH_2O ligand, so their total charge is 5(−1)+0=−55(-1)+0=-5.

The complex carries some overall negative charge, which must balance the two Na+Na^+ ions. Writing the neutrality condition,

2(+1)  +  charge of complex  =  0,2(+1) \;+\; \text{charge of complex} \;=\;0,

so the complex charge is −2-2. Hence

x−5=−2  ⟹  x=+3.x-5=-2 \;\Longrightarrow\; x=+3.

All five chlorides are inside the coordination sphere, and there is no chloride outside. Therefore no AgClAgCl can be formed.

Equivalents of AgNO3AgNO_3 consumed  =  00.

Option B : Na3[CrCl6]Na_3[CrCl_6]

Let chromium have oxidation state xx. Inside the sphere are six Cl−Cl^- ligands, total charge 6(−1)=−66(-1)=-6.

The complex must balance three Na+Na^+ ions:

3(+1)+charge of complex=0  ⟹  charge of complex=−3.3(+1)+\text{charge of complex}=0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{charge of complex}=-3.

Then x−6=−3  ⟹  x=+3.x-6=-3 \;\Longrightarrow\; x=+3.

All six chlorides are inside; none are outside, so again

Equivalents of AgNO3AgNO_3 consumed  =  00.

Option C : [Cr(H2O)5Cl]Cl2[Cr(H_2O)_5Cl]Cl_2

Let chromium have oxidation state xx. Inside we have one Cl−Cl^- and five neutral H2OH_2O molecules, so the ligand charge is −1-1.

The entire salt contains two outside Cl−Cl^- ions. Hence the neutrality condition is

[charge of complex]  +  2(−1)=0  ⟹  charge of complex=+2.\bigl[\text{charge of complex}\bigr] \;+\; 2(-1)=0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{charge of complex}=+2.

Writing the oxidation-state equation,

x+(−1)=+2  ⟹  x=+3.x + (-1)=+2 \;\Longrightarrow\; x=+3.

Therefore exactly two chloride ions lie outside the square brackets and will react with AgNO3AgNO_3.

Equivalents of AgNO3AgNO_3 consumed  =  22.

Option D : [Cr(H2O)6]Cl3[Cr(H_2O)_6]Cl_3

All six ligands inside the sphere are neutral H2OH_2O molecules; their total charge is zero.

The salt has three outside Cl−Cl^- ions. For electrical neutrality,

[charge of complex]  +  3(−1)=0  ⟹  charge of complex=+3.\bigl[\text{charge of complex}\bigr] \;+\; 3(-1)=0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \text{charge of complex}=+3.

Consequently, chromium is in the +3+3 oxidation state, and all three chloride ions remain outside the coordination sphere.

Equivalents of AgNO3AgNO_3 consumed  =  33.

Comparing the numbers obtained,

0  (A)  ,  0  (B)  ,  2  (C)  ,  3  (D)0 \;(\text{A}) \;,\; 0 \;(\text{B}) \;,\; 2 \;(\text{C}) \;,\; 3 \;(\text{D})

we see that Option D provides the maximum of three ionisable chloride ions and therefore requires the greatest number of equivalents of AgNO3AgNO_3.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Valence bond theory of complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicValence bond theory of complexes
TypeMultiple choice