RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 08 JAN S2+4MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Werner's theory and coordination terminology

Complexes (ML5_5) of metals Ni and Fe have ideal square pyramidal and trigonal bipyramidal geometries, respectively. The sum of the 90∘^\circ, 120∘^\circ and 180∘^\circ L-M-L angles in the two complexes is

SOLUTION

First we note that an ML5 complex contains a total of five ligands around the central metal atom, so the total number of possible L-M-L angles is obtained from the combination formula  5C2  =  5×42×1=10.{}^{\,5}C_{2} \;=\; \dfrac{5\times4}{2\times1}=10. Hence, in each ML5 geometry there are ten distinct L-M-L angles. We now have to identify, for the two given geometries, which of those ten angles are exactly 90∘,  120∘ or 180∘.90^{\circ},\;120^{\circ}\text{ or }180^{\circ}.

Square-pyramidal geometry (Ni complex)
In an ideal square pyramid four ligands occupy the corners of a square base (let us label them B1, B2, B3, B4) and one ligand (A) is located axially above the centre of that square.

We classify every pair of ligands and write down the corresponding angle:

1. Axial-basal pairs: A-B1, A-B2, A-B3, A-B4
Each of these four angles is 90∘.90^{\circ}.

2. Adjacent basal pairs: B1-B2, B2-B3, B3-B4, B4-B1
    Since the base is a square, the angle between any two adjacent basal ligands is also 90∘.90^{\circ}.     Thus we get another four 90∘90^{\circ} angles.

3. Opposite basal pairs: B1-B3, B2-B4
    Being diametrically opposite on the square, these two pairs form the straight line angle 180∘.180^{\circ}.

Adding up the square-pyramidal angles that are exactly 90∘,90^{\circ}, 120∘,120^{\circ}, or 180∘:180^{\circ}:

  90∘ angles=4+4=890^{\circ}\text{ angles}=4+4=8
  120∘ angles=0120^{\circ}\text{ angles}=0
  180∘ angles=2180^{\circ}\text{ angles}=2

Trigonal-bipyramidal geometry (Fe complex)
In an ideal trigonal bipyramid three ligands (E1, E2, E3) occupy the equatorial positions forming a perfect triangle, while two ligands (A1, A2) reside axially.

Again we list every type of pair:

1. Axial-equatorial pairs: Each axial ligand makes 90∘90^{\circ} with every equatorial ligand.     Number of such pairs: 2×3=6,2\times 3 = 6, each at 90∘.90^{\circ}.

2. Equatorial-equatorial pairs: The three equatorial ligands lie in a plane with 120∘120^{\circ} between each adjacent pair.     Number of such pairs: 3C2=3,^3C_{2}=3, each at 120∘.120^{\circ}.

3. Axial-axial pair: The two axial ligands are collinear, giving one angle of 180∘.180^{\circ}.

Hence, for the trigonal bipyramid we have

  90∘ angles=690^{\circ}\text{ angles}=6
  120∘ angles=3120^{\circ}\text{ angles}=3
  180∘ angles=1180^{\circ}\text{ angles}=1

Total for both complexes taken together

90∘ angles=8+6=14,120∘ angles=0+3=3,180∘ angles=2+1=3.\begin{aligned} 90^{\circ}\text{ angles}&=8+6=14,\\ 120^{\circ}\text{ angles}&=0+3=3,\\ 180^{\circ}\text{ angles}&=2+1=3. \end{aligned}$

The required sum of the numbers of 90∘,  120∘90^{\circ},\;120^{\circ}\text{ and }180∘180^{\circ} angles is therefore

14+3+3=20.14+3+3 = 20.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Werner's theory and coordination terminology. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicWerner's theory and coordination terminology
TypeNumerical answer