RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 08 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Structural isomerism in complexes

Among (a) - (d), the complexes that can show geometrical isomerism are:
(a) [Pt(NH3_3)3_3Cl]+^+
(b) [Pt(NH3_3)Cl5_5]−^-
(c) [Pt(NH3_3)2_2Cl(NO2_2)]
(d) [Pt(NH3_3)4_4ClBr]2+^{2+}

SOLUTION

We begin by noting that platinum generally forms square-planar complexes in the +2 oxidation state (d8d^8) and octahedral complexes in the +4 oxidation state (d6d^6). Counting the ligands in each formula will therefore tell us the geometry and hence whether geometrical (cis-trans) isomerism is possible.

(a) [Pt(NH3)3Cl]+[{\rm Pt(NH_3)_3Cl}]^{+}
The complex contains four ligands, so the Pt is +2+2 and the geometry is square planar. Its empirical type is MA3BMA_3B where A=NH3A = NH_3 and B=Cl−B = Cl^-. For a square-planar MA3BMA_3B ion, placing the single BB ligand at any one of the four corners and then simply rotating the square makes all arrangements equivalent. Hence there is only one possible arrangement and no cis-trans pair can arise. So, no geometrical isomerism.

(b) [Pt(NH3)Cl5]−[{\rm Pt(NH_3)Cl_5}]^{-}
Here we have six ligands in all, so Pt must be +4+4 and the geometry is octahedral. The formulation is AB5AB_5 with A=NH3A = NH_3 and B=Cl−B = Cl^-. In an octahedron having five identical ligands and one different ligand, whichever position the single AA occupies, all five BB ligands remain equivalent by symmetry; consequently there is still only one possible arrangement. Thus, no geometrical isomerism can occur.

(c) [Pt(NH3)2Cl(NO2)][{\rm Pt(NH_3)_2Cl(NO_2)}]
This complex has four ligands, giving a square-planar +2+2 species. Its type is MA2BCMA_2BC with the identical ligands A=NH3A = NH_3. For a square-planar MA2BCMA_2BC complex, the two identical AA ligands may lie adjacent (cis) or opposite (trans). Hence two distinct geometrical isomers (cis and trans) are possible.

(d) [Pt(NH3)4ClBr]2+[{\rm Pt(NH_3)_4ClBr}]^{2+}
There are six ligands, so again Pt is +4+4 and the geometry is octahedral. The pattern is MA4BCMA_4BC where A=NH3,  B=Cl−,  C=Br−A = NH_3,\; B = Cl^-,\; C = Br^-. In an octahedron of type MA4BCMA_4BC the two different ligands (BB and CC) can be placed either cis (adjacent) or trans (opposite) to each other, producing two geometrical isomers.

Summarising these results:
[Pt(NH3)3Cl]+[{\rm Pt(NH_3)_3Cl}]^{+} - no isomerism;
[Pt(NH3)Cl5]−[{\rm Pt(NH_3)Cl_5}]^{-} - no isomerism;
[Pt(NH3)2Cl(NO2)][{\rm Pt(NH_3)_2Cl(NO_2)}] - shows geometrical isomerism;
[Pt(NH3)4ClBr]2+[{\rm Pt(NH_3)_4ClBr}]^{2+} - shows geometrical isomerism.

Therefore the complexes capable of geometrical isomerism are (c) and (d).

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStructural isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice