RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 08 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Structural isomerism in complexes

The complex that can show fac- and mer-isomers is:

SOLUTION

First, let us recall the precise condition for the appearance of facial-meridional (fac- and mer-) isomerism. The rule is:

An octahedral complex of the general type MA3B3MA_3B_3 (three ligands of kind AA and three of kind B)B)

can arrange the three identical ligands so that either all three occupy the corners of one triangular face of the octahedron (the fac form) or lie on one meridian passing through the metal (the mer form). Only such an MA3B3MA_3B_3 distribution permits these two distinct spatial dispositions.

With the condition now clearly stated, we inspect each given option one by one, explicitly writing each formula in the required MAxByMA_xB_y style and checking whether x=3, y=3x=3,\,y=3 inside an octahedral environment.

Option A: [ Co(NH3)4Cl2 ]+[\,\mathrm{Co}(NH_3)_4Cl_2\,]^+

Here the central metal is CoIII\mathrm{Co^{III}} in an octahedral field. The ligand count is

A=NH3  (4  times),A = NH_3 \;(4\; \text{times}), B=Cl−  (2  times).B = Cl^- \;(2\; \text{times}).

Thus the pattern is MA4B2MA_4B_2, not MA3B3MA_3B_3. Such a complex exhibits only cis-trans isomerism, not fac-mer. Therefore Option A is unsuitable.

Option B: [ Pt(NH3)2Cl2 ][\,\mathrm{Pt}(NH_3)_2Cl_2\,]

Platinum in this complex is PtII\mathrm{Pt^{II}}, which almost always forms a square-planar geometry, not octahedral. Facial-meridional terminology has meaning only for the six-coordinate octahedron, so fac-mer cannot arise here. Hence Option B is ruled out.

Option C: [ CoCl2(en)2 ][\,\mathrm{Co}Cl_2(en)_2\,]

The abbreviation enen denotes ethylenediamine, a bidentate ligand occupying two sites each. Counting sites:

2(en)  ⇒  4 sites occupied,2(en)\;\Rightarrow\;4\text{ sites occupied}, 2Cl−  ⇒  2 sites occupied.2Cl^-\;\Rightarrow\;2\text{ sites occupied}.

The pattern becomes M(A ⁣− ⁣A)2B2M(A\!-\!A)_2B_2 where each (A ⁣− ⁣A)(A\!-\!A) is bidentate. This arrangement again gives only cis-trans possibilities (now with bidentate ligands) and not the required MA3B3MA_3B_3 distribution. So Option C is also unsuitable.

Option D: [ Co(NH3)3(NO2)3 ][\,\mathrm{Co}(NH_3)_3(NO_2)_3\,]

image

Now we count ligands:

A=NH3  (3  times),A = NH_3 \;(3\; \text{times}), B=NO2−  (3  times).B = NO_2^- \;(3\; \text{times}).

This is precisely the MA3B3MA_3B_3 pattern described in the rule above, and the complex is octahedral because CoIII\mathrm{Co^{III}} with six monodentate ligands adopts octahedral geometry. Therefore two distinct spatial arrangements exist:

1. The three NH3NH_3 ligands can occupy corners of one face: the fac isomer.
2. The three NH3NH_3 ligands can lie along a meridian: the mer isomer.

Hence this complex unmistakably exhibits fac- and mer-isomerism.

After examining every option, only Option D satisfies the necessary condition.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStructural isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice