RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 08 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — Crystal field splitting, CFSE and spectrochemical series

Consider the following reaction and statements:
[Co(NH3)4Br2]++Br−→[Co(NH3)3Br3]+NH3[Co(NH_3)_4Br_2]^+ + Br^- \rightarrow [Co(NH_3)_3Br_3] + NH_3
(i) Two isomers are produced if the reactant complex ion is a cis-isomer.
(ii) Two isomers are produced if the reactant complex ion is a trans-isomer.
(iii) Only one isomer is produced if the reactant complex ion is a trans-isomer.
(iv) Only one isomer is produced if the reactant complex ion is a cis-isomer.
The correct statements are:

SOLUTION

We first note that both [Co(NH3)4Br2]+[Co(NH_3)_4Br_2]^+ and [Co(NH3)3Br3][Co(NH_3)_3Br_3] are octahedral Co(III) complexes. In an octahedral field we always imagine six positions situated at the corners of a regular octahedron. Each position is cis ( 90° ) to four others and trans ( 180° ) to the remaining one.

The reactant ion [Co(NH3)4Br2]+[Co(NH_3)_4Br_2]^+ contains two bromido ligands and four ammine ligands, so it has the general formula MA4B2MA_4B_2 (with A=NH3A = NH_3 and B=Br−B = Br^-). Such a complex shows two possible geometries:

• cis- isomer - the two Br−Br^- ligands occupy adjacent positions (90° apart).
• trans-isomer - the two Br−Br^- ligands are opposite each other (180° apart).

The product [Co(NH3)3Br3][Co(NH_3)_3Br_3] has the general formula MA3B3MA_3B_3. For an octahedral MA3B3MA_3B_3 species the textbook tells us that TWO geometrical arrangements are possible:

• fac (facial) - all three Br−Br^- ligands are mutually cis (form one face of the octahedron).
• mer (meridional) - two of the Br−Br^- ligands are trans and the third is cis to both of them.

We now examine how many of these arrangements can actually be produced when one NH3NH_3 of the reactant is replaced by the incoming Br−Br^- ion.

To see this clearly we draw a labelled octahedron. Place the metal at the centre and mark the six sites as

Site 1Site 2Site 3Site 4Site 5Site 6\begin{array}{ccc} \text{Site 1} & \text{Site 2} & \text{Site 3}\\ \text{Site 4} & \text{Site 5} & \text{Site 6} \end{array}

where (1,4), (2,5) and (3,6) are the three trans pairs. We now start with the two Br−Br^- ligands in positions dictated by the chosen isomer of the reactant and then insert a third Br−Br^- into one of the four remaining sites while simultaneously letting one NH3NH_3 leave.

Case 1 - cis-reactant.

Take the two bromido ligands in, say, sites 1 and 2. These are cis. The four empty sites (3,4,5,6) are indistinguishable before substitution. Now add the new Br−Br^- to each possible site and examine the resulting MA3B3MA_3B_3 geometry.

• New Br−Br^- at site 3 - sites 1,2,3 are all mutually cis, giving the fac product.
• New Br−Br^- at site 4 - the new arrangement has site 1 trans to 4, while 2 is cis to both; this corresponds to the mer product.
• New Br−Br^- at site 5 - identical to the previous mer situation by simple rotation.
• New Br−Br^- at site 6 - again gives the same fac product as the first case after rotation.

Therefore both fac and mer products can be formed. Hence two isomers are produced when the reactant is cis. Statement (i) is true, statement (iv) is false.

Case 2 - trans-reactant.

Now place the two bromido ligands in, say, sites 1 and 4 (a trans pair). The vacant sites are 2,3,5,6.

• New Br−Br^- at site 2 - the final complex has bromido ligands in sites 1,2,4. Here 1 is trans to 4 and cis to 2, while 2 is cis to 4. This is the mer arrangement.
• New Br−Br^- at site 3 - by rotation the same mer pattern appears.
• New Br−Br^- at site 5 - likewise gives the identical mer geometry.
• New Br−Br^- at site 6 - again the same mer product.

Because two of the bromido ligands are locked in a trans relation from the start, it is impossible to generate a configuration in which all three are mutually cis; hence the fac form cannot appear. Only the mer isomer is obtainable. So exactly one isomer is formed when the reactant is trans. Statement (iii) is true, statement (ii) is false.

Collecting the valid statements, we have (i) and (iii).

Option C lists statements (i) and (iii).

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Crystal field splitting, CFSE and spectrochemical series. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicCrystal field splitting, CFSE and spectrochemical series
TypeMultiple choice