RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Structural isomerism in complexes

The number of possible optical isomers for the complexes MA2_2B2_2 with sp3^3 and dsp2^2 hybridized metal atom, respectively, is:
Note: A and B are unidentate neutral and unidentate monoanionic ligands, respectively.

SOLUTION

First, we note the hybridisations mentioned:

sp3  ⟹  tetrahedral geometry\text{sp}^3 \; \Longrightarrow \; \text{tetrahedral geometry}$ dsp2  ⟹  square-planar geometry\text{dsp}^2 \; \Longrightarrow \; \text{square-planar geometry}$

Optical isomerism (chirality) is possible only when the complex does not possess any element of symmetry such as a plane of symmetry (σ\sigma), a centre of symmetry (ii) or an improper rotation axis (SnS_n). We now study the two geometries one by one for the formula MA2B2\text{MA}_2\text{B}_2.

For the tetrahedral complex (sp3\text{sp}^3):

The four corners of a tetrahedron are equivalent. If all four ligands were different (MABCD\text{MABCD}) the complex would indeed be chiral. However, in MA2B2\text{MA}_2\text{B}_2 two ligands are identical (A, A\text{A, A}) and the other two are also identical (B, B\text{B, B}). We can always place the two A\text{A} ligands so that they lie opposite each other through a plane that also bisects the angle made by the two B\text{B} ligands. That plane is a mirror plane (σ\sigma) passing through the metal atom and bisecting the tetrahedron. Because of this mirror plane the structure is superposable on its mirror image. Hence it is achiral.

Therefore,

Number of optical isomers for the tetrahedral complex=0\text{Number of optical isomers for the tetrahedral complex} = 0$

For the square-planar complex (dsp2\text{dsp}^2):

A square-planar complex lies entirely in one plane. That plane itself is a mirror plane (σ\sigma) for the molecule. Moreover, the complex also possesses a centre of symmetry (ii) at the metal atom when two opposite positions are the same ligand (which must happen in MA2B2\text{MA}_2\text{B}_2, giving either the cis or the trans arrangement). Because of either the mirror plane (cis form) or the centre of symmetry (trans form) the mirror image is always superposable on the original molecule.

Thus,

Number of optical isomers for the square-planar complex=0\text{Number of optical isomers for the square-planar complex} = 0$

Collecting both results, we have

sp3  (tetrahedral):  0dsp2  (square-planar):  0\begin{aligned} \text{sp}^3\;(\text{tetrahedral}): & \; 0 \\ \text{dsp}^2\;(\text{square-planar}): & \; 0 \end{aligned}$

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStructural isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice