RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Colour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT

The theory that can completely/properly explain the nature of bonding in [Ni(CO)4_4] is:

SOLUTION

We begin with the species in question, [Ni(CO)4][ \text{Ni(CO)}_4 ], which is a typical metal carbonyl. The atomic number of nickel is 2828, so an isolated Ni\text{Ni} atom has the ground-state electronic configuration [Ar] 3d8 4s2[ \text{Ar} ]\,3d^{8}\,4s^{2}. In the complex the nickel is in the zero oxidation state, so it still possesses a total of 1010 valence electrons (3d84s2)\bigl(3d^{8}4s^{2}\bigr).

The 18-electron rule (which is only an electron-counting guideline) states that a stable transition-metal complex often achieves a valence electron count of 1818. Applying the rule, we write

Electron count of the complex=Metal valence electrons+Electrons donated by ligands.\text{Electron count of the complex}= \text{Metal valence electrons} + \text{Electrons donated by ligands}.

Each neutral carbonyl ligand CO\text{CO} donates a pair of electrons (σ\sigma donation), so four CO\text{CO} ligands supply 4×2=84 \times 2 = 8 electrons. Adding these to the metal’s 1010 electrons,

10+8=18,10 + 8 = 18,

so the complex satisfies the 18-electron rule. While this arithmetic explains why [Ni(CO)4][ \text{Ni(CO)}_4 ] is stable, it gives no insight into the actual nature of the bonding.

Now we recall that the CO\text{CO} ligand is a strong σ\sigma donor and a strong π\pi acceptor. Thus two simultaneous interactions operate:

CO  :  σ-donor  ( lone pair on C → empty orbital on Ni )\text{CO}\;:\; \sigma\text{-donor}\; (\,\text{lone pair on C}\,\rightarrow\,\text{empty orbital on Ni}\,)

CO  :  π-acceptor  ( filled Ni 3d → π∗ of CO )\text{CO}\;:\; \pi\text{-acceptor}\; (\,\text{filled Ni }3d\,\rightarrow\,\pi^* \text{ of CO}\,)

This synergic σ\sigma donation and π\pi back-donation cannot be described adequately by simple electrostatic models. Let us examine each candidate theory:

Werner’s theory treats coordination merely in terms of primary and secondary valencies; it does not discuss σ\sigma and π\pi orbital overlap, so it fails.

Crystal Field Theory (CFT) improves on Werner by introducing the splitting of metal dd-orbitals in an electrostatic field of point charges. However, CFT still treats the metal-ligand bond as purely ionic; it cannot account for covalent π\pi back-bonding into the ligand’s π∗\pi^* orbitals, so it is insufficient.

Valence Bond Theory (VBT) does allow for hybridisation (here one could write an sp3sp^3 set on Ni to obtain a tetrahedral shape), but VBT is essentially a localized, two-centre-two-electron picture and likewise has no place for the delocalised π\pi back-donation that is essential in metal carbonyl chemistry.

Molecular Orbital Theory (MOT), on the other hand, constructs delocalised orbitals that extend over both metal and ligands. In the MO diagram of [Ni(CO)4][ \text{Ni(CO)}_4 ] we explicitly include:

• a set of ligand-based σ\sigma orbitals combining with metal ss, pp and dsp3d_{sp^3} hybrids to form bonding and antibonding σ\sigma MOs, and

• a set of metal dπd_{\pi} orbitals overlapping with the ligand π∗\pi^* orbitals to form bonding π\pi MOs (back-bonding) that stabilize the complex and lower the C-O stretching frequency observed experimentally.

Because MOT simultaneously handles σ\sigma donation, π\pi back-donation, the 18-electron count, and spectroscopic consequences, it is the only theory in the list that can completely and properly explain the bonding in [Ni(CO)4][ \text{Ni(CO)}_4 ].

Hence, the correct answer is Option 2.

Tagged Colour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicColour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT
TypeMultiple choice