RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2014 · 06 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2014 Chemistry question — Werner's theory and coordination terminology

The equation which is balanced and represents the correct product(s) is:

SOLUTION

We examine every alternative one by one, always checking two things: first, whether the skeleton is stoichiometrically balanced (atoms as well as total charge); second, whether the chemistry that has been written is actually what happens under the stated conditions.

We have for option A

Li2O+2KCl  →  2LiCl+K2OLi_2O + 2KCl \;\rightarrow\; 2LiCl + K_2O

Atom count:

Left side - Li=2,  O=1,  K=2,  Cl=2Li=2,\;O=1,\;K=2,\;Cl=2
Right side - Li=2,  O=1,  K=2,  Cl=2Li=2,\;O=1,\;K=2,\;Cl=2

So the equation is algebraically balanced. However an exchange between two normal, non-volatile salts in the solid state will proceed only if one of the possible products is a gas, a precipitate or a weak electrolyte. Both LiClLiCl and K2OK_2O are ordinary salts; no driving force such as volatility or precipitation is present, and lattice-energy considerations in fact favour the original combination rather than the exchanged one (the small highly charged O2−O^{2-} ion prefers the smaller Li+Li^+ ion). Hence the reaction does not take place; the equation, although arithmetically balanced, does not represent the correct chemistry.

Now option B:

[CoCl(NH3)5]++5H+  →  Co2++5NH4++Cl−[CoCl(NH_3)_5]^+ + 5H^+ \;\rightarrow\; Co^{2+} + 5NH_4^+ + Cl^-

First, we verify the atom balance.

Left - Co=1,  Cl=1,  N=5,  H=5  (outside the ligands)+15  (in 5NH3)=20Co=1,\;Cl=1,\;N=5,\;H=5\;(\text{outside the ligands}) + 15\;(\text{in } 5NH_3)=20

Right - Co=1,  Cl=1,  N=5,  H=5×4(in NH4+)=20Co=1,\;Cl=1,\;N=5,\;H=5\times4(\text{in }NH_4^+)=20

Hence atoms match. Now for the total charge:

Left-hand charge =   (+1)+5(+1)=+6\;(+1) + 5(+1)= +6

Right-hand charge = (+2)+5(+1)+(−1)=+6(+2)+5(+1)+(-1)= +6

The charges also match. From the chemical point of view, concentrated acid protonates each NH3NH_3 ligand to form NH4+NH_4^+; the mutually bound chloride leaves as Cl−Cl^- and the cobalt centre is reduced from +3 to +2 by internal redox in which the coordinated ammonia is very slowly oxidised (no external reducing agent is required because the process is intramolecular). Thus the products quoted are exactly those observed. The equation is therefore both balanced and chemically correct.

Consider option C:

[Mg(H2O)6]2++(EDTA)4−  →excess NaOH  [Mg(EDTA)]2−+6H2O[Mg(H_2O)_6]^{2+} + (EDTA)^{4-} \;\xrightarrow{\text{excess NaOH}}\; [Mg(EDTA)]^{2-} + 6H_2O

The arithmetic balance is fine, but the experimental fact is that when a very strong excess of NaOHNaOH is present, the hexaaquamanganese(II) ion precipitates as Mg(OH)2Mg(OH)_2 long before the EDTA can capture it. In other words, under “excess NaOH” conditions the dominant product is a solid hydroxide, not the soluble EDTA chelate. So the equation does not describe the real outcome and must be rejected.

Finally option D:

CuSO4+4KCN  →  K2[Cu(CN)4]+K2SO4CuSO_4 + 4KCN \;\rightarrow\; K_2[Cu(CN)_4] + K_2SO_4

At a first glance the atoms appear balanced (there are four KK atoms, one CuCu atom, one SS atom, four CNCN groups and four OO atoms on each side). Nevertheless, when excess cyanide reacts with Cu2+Cu^{2+} the sequence is:

Cu2++2CN−  →  Cu(CN)2 ⁣↓Cu^{2+} + 2CN^- \;\rightarrow\; Cu(CN)_2\!\downarrow (a white precipitate)

Cu(CN)2+2CN−  →  [Cu(CN)4]3−+Cu+Cu(CN)_2 + 2CN^- \;\rightarrow\; [Cu(CN)_4]^{3-} + Cu^+

The Cu+Cu^+ liberated then combines with another portion of the complex to give a mixture whose overall composition corresponds to K3[Cu(CN)4]K_3[Cu(CN)_4], never K2[Cu(CN)4]K_2[Cu(CN)_4]. Moreover, the accompanying sulphate remains as K2SO4K_2SO_4 only after a second equivalent of KCNKCN is introduced. Hence the single, neatly written equation in the option does not match the actual multi-step chemistry; the stoichiometry of potassium ions is also wrong. Thus option D is not acceptable.

Out of the four alternatives, only option B satisfies both the mathematical balance and the true chemical behaviour.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Werner's theory and coordination terminology. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicWerner's theory and coordination terminology
TypeMultiple choice