Consider the complex ions, trans- (A) and cis- (B). The correct statement regarding them is:
First of all, denotes ethylenediamine, , which is a bidentate ligand. In the octahedral complex the cobalt(III) centre is surrounded by two chelating ligands and two monodentate chloride ligands.
Optical activity arises when a molecule or ion is chiral, that is, when it is not super-imposable on its mirror image. The necessary and sufficient condition for chirality in an octahedral complex is the absence of any improper symmetry element (plane of symmetry , centre of inversion or an axis). Whenever such a symmetry element is present, the complex is achiral and therefore cannot show optical activity.
We now examine the two geometrical isomers one by one.
Trans- (A): In the trans isomer, the two chloride ions occupy positions opposite each other (i.e. a 180° angle). The two chelate rings are therefore arranged so that the entire ion contains a vertical mirror plane passing through cobalt, cutting the octahedron into two identical halves: one half contains one arm from the first ligand and one from the second ligand together with a chloride, and the other half is its mirror image with the second chloride. Because this mirror plane exists, the complex possesses an improper symmetry element, making the ion achiral. Consequently,
Cis- (B): In the cis isomer, the two chloride ligands are adjacent (90° apart). Now try to locate any mirror plane or centre of inversion:
• A plane that would pass through cobalt and both chlorides fails to bisect the two rings symmetrically because each ligand wraps around the metal in a fixed sense (left-handed or right-handed twist).
• There is no centre of inversion; the positions of donor nitrogen atoms from do not come in opposite pairs across cobalt.
• No (improper fourfold) or higher improper axis is present because of the asymmetrical chelate rings.
Therefore no improper symmetry element exists. The ion is chiral and occurs as two non-super-imposable mirror images (Δ and Λ forms). Hence,
Putting the results together, we have:
So the trans isomer cannot be optically active, while the cis isomer can be optically active.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.