The values of the crystal field stabilization energies for a high spin metal ion in octahedral and tetrahedral fields, respectively, are:
In crystal field theory we have two standard splitting patterns.
• For an octahedral field the three lower orbitals are designated and lie at an energy of each, while the two upper orbitals are designated and lie at each. The crystal-field stabilisation energy (CFSE) is therefore written as
where and are the numbers of electrons in the respective sets.
• For a tetrahedral field the relative ordering is reversed and the magnitudes are smaller. The two lower orbitals are labelled and lie at each, while the three upper orbitals are labelled and lie at each. Thus
Now we deal with a high-spin ion.
1. Octahedral field
In a weak (high-spin) octahedral field the six electrons are filled according to Hund’s rule until every orbital of the lower set is singly occupied; only then does pairing begin:
So we have
Substituting and in the octahedral CFSE expression,
2. Tetrahedral field
In a weak (high-spin) tetrahedral field the lower set is filled first with one electron in each orbital before electrons enter the higher set; pairing is avoided until every orbital is singly occupied:
Stepwise filling gives after five electrons; the sixth electron must now pair in the lower set, producing
Thus and
Putting these numbers into the tetrahedral CFSE expression,
We have therefore obtained and which exactly matches the pair of values listed in Option A.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Colour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.