RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Colour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT

The values of the crystal field stabilization energies for a high spin d6d^6 metal ion in octahedral and tetrahedral fields, respectively, are:

SOLUTION

In crystal field theory we have two standard splitting patterns.

• For an octahedral field the three lower orbitals are designated t2gt_{2g} and lie at an energy of −0.4 Δo-0.4\,\Delta_o each, while the two upper orbitals are designated ege_g and lie at +0.6 Δo+0.6\,\Delta_o each. The crystal-field stabilisation energy (CFSE) is therefore written as

CFSEocta=(−0.4 Δo)  n(t2g)+(+0.6 Δo)  m(eg),\text{CFSE}_\text{octa} = (-0.4\,\Delta_o)\;n(t_{2g}) + (+0.6\,\Delta_o)\;m(e_g),

where n(t2g)n(t_{2g}) and m(eg)m(e_g) are the numbers of electrons in the respective sets.

• For a tetrahedral field the relative ordering is reversed and the magnitudes are smaller. The two lower orbitals are labelled ee and lie at −0.6 Δt-0.6\,\Delta_t each, while the three upper orbitals are labelled t2t_2 and lie at +0.4 Δt+0.4\,\Delta_t each. Thus

CFSEtetra=(−0.6 Δt)  n(e)+(+0.4 Δt)  m(t2).\text{CFSE}_\text{tetra} = (-0.6\,\Delta_t)\;n(e) + (+0.4\,\Delta_t)\;m(t_2).

Now we deal with a high-spin d6d^6 ion.

1. Octahedral field

In a weak (high-spin) octahedral field the six electrons are filled according to Hund’s rule until every orbital of the lower set is singly occupied; only then does pairing begin:

t2g:↑  ↑  ↑⇒↑↓t_{2g}: \uparrow\;\uparrow\;\uparrow \quad\Rightarrow\quad \uparrow\downarrow eg:  ↑  ↑e_g:\; \uparrow\;\uparrow

So we have t2g4 eg2.t_{2g}^4\,e_g^2.

Substituting n(t2g)=4n(t_{2g}) = 4 and m(eg)=2m(e_g) = 2 in the octahedral CFSE expression,

CFSEocta=(−0.4 Δo)(4)+(+0.6 Δo)(2)\text{CFSE}_\text{octa} = (-0.4\,\Delta_o)(4) + (+0.6\,\Delta_o)(2) =−1.6 Δo+1.2 Δo= -1.6\,\Delta_o + 1.2\,\Delta_o =−0.4 Δo.= -0.4\,\Delta_o.

2. Tetrahedral field

In a weak (high-spin) tetrahedral field the lower ee set is filled first with one electron in each orbital before electrons enter the higher t2t_2 set; pairing is avoided until every orbital is singly occupied:

Stepwise filling gives e2 t23e^2\,t_2^3 after five electrons; the sixth electron must now pair in the lower set, producing e3 t23.e^3\,t_2^3.

Thus n(e)=3n(e) = 3 and m(t2)=3.m(t_2) = 3.

Putting these numbers into the tetrahedral CFSE expression,

CFSEtetra=(−0.6 Δt)(3)+(+0.4 Δt)(3)\text{CFSE}_\text{tetra} = (-0.6\,\Delta_t)(3) + (+0.4\,\Delta_t)(3) =−1.8 Δt+1.2 Δt= -1.8\,\Delta_t + 1.2\,\Delta_t =−0.6 Δt.= -0.6\,\Delta_t.

We have therefore obtained CFSEocta=−0.4 Δo\text{CFSE}_\text{octa} = -0.4\,\Delta_o and CFSEtetra=−0.6 Δt,\text{CFSE}_\text{tetra} = -0.6\,\Delta_t, which exactly matches the pair of values listed in Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Colour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicColour and magnetic behaviour of complexes from CFT
TypeMultiple choice