RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 03 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Structural isomerism in complexes

The complex that can show optical activity is:

SOLUTION

First, recall the basic rule for optical activity (chirality) in coordination compounds. A complex will be optically active if it does not possess any internal element of symmetry - that is, it must lack a plane of symmetry, a centre of symmetry and an improper rotation axis. In octahedral complexes this usually happens when:

(i)\text{(i)} at least two bidentate (chelating) ligands are present, because the left-handed (Λ\Lambda) and right-handed (Δ\Delta) chelate orientations then become non-superimposable mirror images, and

(ii)\text{(ii)} the ligands are arranged in the cis fashion; a trans arrangement normally introduces a mirror plane or a centre of symmetry, destroying chirality.

With this in mind we examine each option.

Option A: trans - [Cr(Cl2)(ox)2]3−[Cr(Cl_2)(ox)_2]^{3-}

The complex is octahedral with two bidentate ox2−ox^{2-} ligands and two monodentate Cl−Cl^- ligands placed opposite each other (trans). Because the two Cl−Cl^- ions are exactly opposite, we can draw a mirror plane passing through both Cl−Cl^- ions and bisecting the complex. Hence a plane of symmetry exists, so

⇒optically inactive.\Rightarrow \text{optically inactive.}

Option B: trans - [Fe(NH3)2(CN)4]−[Fe(NH_3)_2(CN)_4]^-

All six ligands here are monodentate. With four CN−CN^- and two NH3NH_3 ligands in a trans arrangement, the complex certainly has a centre of symmetry lying at the metal ion because each ligand is matched by an identical ligand directly opposite to it:

⇒optically inactive.\Rightarrow \text{optically inactive.}

Option C: cis - [Fe(NH3)2(CN)4]−[Fe(NH_3)_2(CN)_4]^-

Although this is a cis isomer, all ligands are still monodentate. We can place a vertical mirror plane that passes through the two NH3NH_3 ligands and bisects two opposite CN−CN^- ligands, so the complex possesses a plane of symmetry:

⇒optically inactive.\Rightarrow \text{optically inactive.}

Option D: cis - [CrCl2(ox)2]3−[CrCl_2(ox)_2]^{3-}

Here we have two bidentate ox2−ox^{2-} ligands and two monodentate Cl−Cl^- ligands arranged cis to each other. Because the oxalate ligands wrap around the metal centre in two possible screw-like fashions, we obtain a pair of mirror images - the Λ\Lambda (left-handed) and Δ\Delta (right-handed) forms - which cannot be superimposed on one another. The cis disposition removes any centre or plane of symmetry, so

⇒the complex is optically active.\Rightarrow \text{the complex is optically active.}

Comparing all four cases, only Option D satisfies the criteria for optical activity.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.

Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStructural isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice