Given below are two statements :
Statement I: is square planar and diamagnetic complex, with hybridization for Ni but is tetrahedral, paramagnetic and with hybridication for Ni.
Statement II : and both have same d-electron configuration, have same geometry and are paramagnetic.
In light the above statements, choose the correct answer form the options given below
We need to evaluate both statements about nickel complexes.
Background: Nickel electronic configuration
has atomic number 28:
: (2 unpaired electrons)
: (in complexes, effectively with strong field ligands)
Analysis of Statement I:
:
- has configuration
- is a strong field ligand, so it forces pairing of electrons
- The two unpaired electrons in pair up, vacating one 3d orbital
- Hybridization: square planar geometry
- All electrons are paired diamagnetic
This part of Statement I is correct.
:
- is in zero oxidation state ():
- is a very strong field ligand (causes pairing)
- In , the effective configuration becomes as the 4s electrons move to 3d orbitals
- With all 3d orbitals filled, the hybridization is tetrahedral
- All electrons are paired is diamagnetic, NOT paramagnetic
Statement I says is paramagnetic, which is wrong.
Therefore, Statement I is FALSE.
Analysis of Statement II:
:
- : (2 unpaired electrons)
- is a weak field ligand no pairing of electrons
- Hybridization: tetrahedral geometry
- Has 2 unpaired electrons paramagnetic
:
- As analyzed above: configuration
- tetrahedral geometry
- All electrons paired diamagnetic
Statement II claims both have the same d-electron configuration, same geometry, and are both paramagnetic.
- d-electron configurations are different: () vs ()
- Both are tetrahedral (same geometry) — this is correct
- is diamagnetic, not paramagnetic — this is wrong
Therefore, Statement II is also FALSE.
The correct answer is Option D: Both Statement I and Statement II are false.
Tagged Valence bond theory of complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.