RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2013 · 22 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2013 Chemistry question — Valence bond theory of complexes

Which of the following is diamagnetic?

SOLUTION

We have to decide which of the four octahedral coordination entities is diamagnetic, that is, which one possesses no unpaired electron. A complex is diamagnetic when the total number of unpaired electrons, nu,n_u, is zero. The standard plan is to find, for every complex,

1. the oxidation state of the central metal ion,
2. its corresponding ground-state dd electron count,
3. whether the ligand set produces a high-spin (weak-field) or low-spin (strong-field) splitting,
4. the distribution of those dd electrons into the octahedral levels t2gt_{2g} and eg,e_g, and finally
5. the value of nu.n_u.

First recall the octahedral crystal-field diagram: in octahedral geometry the five dd orbitals split into the lower-energy triply degenerate t2gt_{2g} set and the higher-energy doubly degenerate ege_g set. When the ligands are strong-field (large Δ0\Delta_0), electrons pair inside t2gt_{2g} first (low-spin); when the ligands are weak-field (small Δ0\Delta_0), Hund’s rule dominates and electrons spread into ege_g before pairing (high-spin).

With that background we examine each option one by one.

Option A : [Fe(CN)6]3−[Fe(CN)_6]^{3-}

We first compute the oxidation state of iron. The charge on each CN−CN^- ligand is −1,-1, so for six ligands the total ligand charge is 6(−1)=−6.6(-1)=-6. The overall complex carries −3.-3. Writing the balance, x+(−6)=−3  ⟹  x=+3.x + (-6)= -3 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = +3. Hence the central ion is Fe3+.Fe^{3+}.

The atomic number of iron is 26,26, so the neutral configuration is [Ar] 3d64s2.[Ar]\,3d^6 4s^2. Removing three electrons for Fe3+Fe^{3+} leaves Fe3+:3d5.Fe^{3+} : 3d^5.

The ligand CN−CN^- is a classic strong-field ligand (spectrochemical series). Therefore the complex is low-spin. In an octahedral low-spin arrangement five electrons fill the lower t2gt_{2g} orbitals as t2g5 eg0.t_{2g}^5\,e_g^0. The orbital diagram shows four paired electrons and one left unpaired, so nu=1  ≠0.n_u =1 \;\neq 0. Hence the complex is paramagnetic, not diamagnetic.

Option B : [Co(ox)3]3−[Co(ox)_3]^{3-}   (here ox2−=C2O42−ox^{2-}=C_2O_4^{2-})

Let us again evaluate the oxidation state. Each oxalate carries −2,-2, so x+3(−2)=−3  ⟹  x=+3.x + 3(-2) = -3 \;\Longrightarrow\; x = +3. Therefore we have Co3+.Co^{3+}.

Cobalt’s atomic number is 27,27, giving the neutral configuration [Ar] 3d74s2.[Ar]\,3d^7 4s^2. Removal of three electrons yields Co3+:3d6.Co^{3+} : 3d^6.

Now we decide whether the complex is high-spin or low-spin. Oxalate is a bidentate ligand that lies in the mid-to-strong field region; more importantly, the central ion bears a high charge +3,+3, which enhances the crystal-field splitting. Experimentally the majority of Co3+Co^{3+} octahedral chelates, including [Co(ox)3]3−,[Co(ox)_3]^{3-}, are low-spin. We shall therefore fill the six dd electrons into the low-spin pattern: t2g6 eg0.t_{2g}^6\,e_g^0. All six electrons are now paired inside the lower level, so nu=0.n_u = 0. Because no unpaired electrons remain, the complex is diamagnetic.

Option C : [FeF6]3−[FeF_6]^{3-}

The oxidation-state calculation is identical to Option A, because each F−F^- contributes −1.-1. We again find Fe3+:3d5.Fe^{3+} : 3d^5.

The ligand F−F^- is a very weak-field ligand. Hence the complex will be high-spin. In an octahedral high-spin d5d^5 configuration the electrons distribute as t2g3 eg2,t_{2g}^3\,e_g^2, one in each orbital, giving nu=5.n_u = 5. Five unpaired electrons make the substance strongly paramagnetic, so it is not diamagnetic.

Option D : [CoF6]3−[CoF_6]^{3-}

Again taking six F−F^- ligands, we find Co3+:3d6.Co^{3+} : 3d^6.

Because F−F^- is a weak-field ligand, the splitting is small and the complex remains high-spin. For a high-spin d6d^6 ion we obtain t2g4 eg2,t_{2g}^4\,e_g^2, with the four t2gt_{2g} electrons arranged as three unpaired and one paired, plus two unpaired in eg,e_g, giving nu=4.n_u = 4. Therefore the complex is paramagnetic, not diamagnetic.

Summarising the counts:

[Fe(CN)6]3−:nu=1(paramagnetic)[Fe(CN)_6]^{3-}: n_u = 1 \quad (\text{paramagnetic})
[Co(ox)3]3−:nu=0(diamagnetic)[Co(ox)_3]^{3-}: n_u = 0 \quad (\text{diamagnetic})
[FeF6]3−:nu=5(paramagnetic)[FeF_6]^{3-}: n_u = 5 \quad (\text{paramagnetic})
[CoF6]3−:nu=4(paramagnetic)[CoF_6]^{3-}: n_u = 4 \quad (\text{paramagnetic})

Only the second complex, [Co(ox)3]3−,[Co(ox)_3]^{3-}, has zero unpaired electrons. Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Valence bond theory of complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicValence bond theory of complexes
TypeMultiple choice