RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2012TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2012 Chemistry question — Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes

The complex ion [Pt(NO2)(Py)(NH3)(NH2OH)]+[Pt(NO_2)(Py)(NH_3)(NH_2OH)]^+ will give

SOLUTION

The oxidation state of platinum in [Pt(NO2)(Py)(NH3)(NH2OH)]+[Pt(NO_2)(Py)(NH_3)(NH_2OH)]^{+} is +2+2 (all ligands except NO2−NO_2^- are neutral, so the charge on the complex is +1+1 and therefore PtPt is +2+2).
Pt2+Pt^{2+} almost always forms square-planar complexes (coordination number 44).

Square-planar geometrical isomerism arises from different pairs of ligands being trans (180° apart) or cis (90° apart).
If all four ligands were identical there would be only one arrangement, but here we have four different monodentate ligands: NO2−NO_2^-, PyPy, NH3NH_3 and NH2OHNH_2OH.

For a square-planar complex of the type [M A B C D][M\,A\,B\,C\,D] (all ligands different) the possible distinct geometrical isomers can be counted as follows:

1. Fix one ligand (say AA) at the top position; because rotation within the plane does not create a new isomer, this “locks” the plane’s orientation.
2. Now place a second ligand trans to AA. Three different choices are available for this trans partner (any of B,C,DB, C, D).
3. After the trans pair is chosen, the remaining two ligands automatically occupy the remaining two positions and are cis to each other. Interchanging those two remaining ligands is only a rotation of the square plane and therefore does not generate a new isomer.

Hence the total number of distinct square-planar arrangements for [M A B C D][M\,A\,B\,C\,D] is 33.

Applying this to [Pt(NO2)(Py)(NH3)(NH2OH)]+[Pt(NO_2)(Py)(NH_3)(NH_2OH)]^{+} with
A=Py,  B=NO2−,  C=NH3,  D=NH2OH,A = Py,\; B = NO_2^-,\; C = NH_3,\; D = NH_2OH, we obtain the three geometrical isomers:

Case 1: PyPy trans NO2−NO_2^-   (therefore NH3NH_3 cis NH2OHNH_2OH)

Case 2: PyPy trans NH3NH_3   (therefore NO2−NO_2^- cis NH2OHNH_2OH)

Case 3: PyPy trans NH2OHNH_2OH   (therefore NO2−NO_2^- cis NH3NH_3)

No further distinct arrangements are possible; any attempt to draw another diagram can be rotated into one of the above three.

Therefore the complex ion exhibits exactly 33 geometrical (cis-trans) isomers.

Option B which is: 3 isomers (Geometrical)

Tagged Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeometrical and optical isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice