RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2010TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2010 Chemistry question — Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes

Which one of the following has an optical isomer? (en = ethylenediamine)

SOLUTION

Optical isomerism (chirality) is observed only when the complex has no plane of symmetry (σ), no centre of symmetry (i) and no improper rotation axis (Sn).
Typical situations that fulfil this requirement are:

(i) Octahedral complexes of the type [M(AA)3][\text{M}(AA)_3] where AAAA is an unsymmetrical bidentate ligand such as ethylenediamine (en).
(ii) Tetrahedral complexes of the form MABCD\text{MABCD} with four different monodentate ligands.

Let us examine every option.

Option A : [Zn(en)(NH3)2]2+[\text{Zn}(\text{en})(\text{NH}_3)_2]^{2+}
Zn(II) with coordination number 4 adopts a tetrahedral geometry. Two ligands are identical (NH3,NH3\text{NH}_3, \text{NH}_3), so the tetrahedron contains a plane that bisects the en\text{en} chelate ring and exchanges the two NH3\text{NH}_3 ligands. Hence the complex is achiral and shows no optical isomerism.

Option B : [Co(en)3]3+[\text{Co}(\text{en})_3]^{3+}
This is an octahedral complex containing three bidentate en\text{en} ligands. The three chelate rings can wind around the metal centre in a right-handed (Δ) or a left-handed (Λ) sense, producing two non-superimposable mirror images. There is no plane, centre or Sn axis of symmetry, so the Δ and Λ forms are true optical isomers.

Option C : [Co(H2O)4(en)]3+[\text{Co}(\text{H}_2\text{O})_4(\text{en})]^{3+}
Although the coordination number is 6, four positions are occupied by identical H2O\text{H}_2\text{O} ligands. A vertical plane can be drawn that passes through the en\text{en} ring and divides the four aquo ligands into two identical pairs. Therefore the complex possesses a plane of symmetry and cannot be chiral.

Option D : [Zn(en)2]2+[\text{Zn}(\text{en})_2]^{2+}
With two identical bidentate ligands around Zn(II) (coordination number 4), the geometry is tetrahedral (or distorted tetrahedral). A plane passing through the metal and bisecting both en\text{en} rings interchanges the two chelates, rendering the structure achiral.

Only Option B lacks all symmetry elements that would destroy chirality, hence it exhibits optical isomerism.

Final answer: Option B which is: [Co(en)3]3+[\text{Co}(\text{en})_3]^{3+}

Tagged Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeometrical and optical isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice