RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2009TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2009 Chemistry question — Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes

Which of the following has an optical isomer?

SOLUTION

A coordination complex exhibits optical isomerism if its structure is chiral, meaning it lacks an improper axis of rotation (most commonly checked as lacking a plane of symmetry, σ\sigma, and a center of inversion, ii). This allows it to exist as non-superimposable mirror images (enantiomers).

  • Monodentate ligands alone in symmetric arrangements (like square planar or octahedral complexes with high symmetry) rarely form chiral centers unless configured asymmetric mixed-ligand types.
  • Bidentate chelating ligands like ethylenediamine (en\text{en}) form stable rings that constrain the geometry. In octahedral complexes, having two or more bidentate ligands frequently creates a helical skew, eliminating planes of symmetry and producing optically active cis isomers.

Analysis of the Complexes:

  • Option A: [Co(NH3)3Cl]+[\text{Co(NH}_3)_3\text{Cl}]^+

    This formula represents a coordination number of 4. Assuming a standard tetrahedral or square planar geometry, the distribution of three identical ligands and one distinct ligand creates a highly symmetric layout with multiple planes of symmetry. It is optically inactive.


  • Option B: [Co(en)(NH3)2]2+[\text{Co(en)(NH}_3)_2]^{2+}

    This complex also possesses a lower coordination number environment where the single bidentate ligand along with two ammine groups coordinates symmetrically, yielding a configuration that contains an internal plane of symmetry. It is optically inactive.


  • Option C: [Co(H2O)4en]3+[\text{Co(H}_2\text{O})_4\text{en}]^{3+}

    This is an octahedral complex of the general formula [M(AA)B4][\text{M(AA)B}_4]. The single ethylenediamine ring lies entirely within one plane, and a plane of symmetry can easily be drawn that cuts directly through the ethylenediamine ring and bisects the pairs of aquo (H2O\text{H}_2\text{O}) ligands. Because it possesses a plane of symmetry, it cannot exhibit optical isomerism.


  • Option D: [Co(en)2NH3)2]3+[\text{Co(en)}_2\text{NH}_3)_2]^{3+}

    This is an octahedral complex of the general formula [M(AA)2B2][\text{M(AA)}_2\text{B}_2]. It can exist as two distinct geometric isomers:

    1. trans-isomer: The two monodenate NH3\text{NH}_3 ligands are positioned at 180∘180^\circ to each other. This form has a center of inversion and planes of symmetry, making it optically inactive.
    2. cis-isomer: The two mono-dentate NH3\text{NH}_3 ligands are located adjacent (90∘90^\circ) to each other. This forces the two chelating en\text{en} rings into a non-planar, propeller-like skew layout. The cis-form lacks any plane of symmetry or center of inversion, separating into a pair of non-superimposable dextro (dd) and levo (ll) enantiomers.

    Because its cis geometric variant is chiral, this complex exhibits optical isomerism.


Conclusion:

Only the complex containing two bidentate ethylenediamine ligands, [Co(en)2NH3)2]3+[\text{Co(en)}_2\text{NH}_3)_2]^{3+}, can form a non-superimposable mirror image geometry via its cis-isomer config.

Answer: Option D — [Co(en)2NH3)2]3+[\text{Co(en)}_2\text{NH}_3)_2]^{3+}

Tagged Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeometrical and optical isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice