RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 02 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Valence bond theory of complexes

For octahedral Mn(II) and tetrahedral Ni(II) complexes, consider the following statements:
(I) both the complexes can be high spin.
(II) Ni(II) complex can very rarely be of low spin.
(III) with strong field ligands, Mn(II) complexes can be low spin.
(IV) aqueous solution of Mn(II) ions is yellow in color.
The correct statements are:

SOLUTION

First, we identify the electronic configurations of the metal ions in their ground state (gas phase): Mn has atomic number 25 and Ni has 28. Removing two s-electrons for the +2 state gives

Mn2+:[Ar] 3d5,\text{Mn}^{2+}: [\text{Ar}]\,3d^5,

Ni2+:[Ar] 3d8.\text{Ni}^{2+}: [\text{Ar}]\,3d^8.

We now examine the two geometries mentioned.

For an octahedral field the crystal-field splitting is denoted by Δo\Delta_o, while for a tetrahedral field the splitting is smaller, Δt=49 Δo.\Delta_t=\dfrac{4}{9}\,\Delta_o. High-spin or low-spin behaviour is governed by a comparison of this splitting with the intra-electronic pairing energy P.P. The rule is:

If Δ<P\Delta \lt P, electrons occupy the higher set of orbitals before pairing →\rightarrow high spin.
If Δ>P\Delta \gt P, electrons pair in the lower set first →\rightarrow low spin.

Statement (I): “Both the complexes can be high spin.”

• Octahedral Mn2+\text{Mn}^{2+} is a d5d^5 system. Because Δo\Delta_o for an ion in the +2 state is moderate, Δo<P\Delta_o\lt P in almost every ligand environment, so the configuration is generally high-spin t2g3eg2t_{2g}^3e_g^2 (five unpaired electrons).
• Tetrahedral Ni2+\text{Ni}^{2+} is a d8d^8 system. With Δt\Delta_t being only 49Δo,\dfrac49\Delta_o, we certainly have Δt<P,\Delta_t\lt P, giving the high-spin configuration e4t24e^4t_2^4 (two unpaired electrons).
Since each complex indeed can exist in a high-spin form, statement (I) is true.

Statement (II): “Ni(II) complex can very rarely be of low spin.”

A tetrahedral field has a small splitting; to obtain low spin we would require an extraordinarily large Δt\Delta_t (i.e., an exceptionally strong field ligand set). Achieving Δt>P\Delta_t\gt P under tetrahedral geometry is practically impossible, though a handful of isolated cases are known in the literature. Thus low-spin tetrahedral Ni2+\text{Ni}^{2+} is very rare, exactly as the statement says. Hence statement (II) is true.

Statement (III): “With strong field ligands, Mn(II) complexes can be low spin.”

For Mn2+(d5)\text{Mn}^{2+}(d^5) in an octahedral field, low spin would mean the electrons all go into the lower set, t2g5eg0,t_{2g}^5e_g^0, giving one unpaired electron. To force this, we need Δo>P.\Delta_o\gt P. Although unusual (because +2 oxidation state gives a relatively small splitting), it is possible with sufficiently strong field ligands such as CN−, CO, or phosphines containing π-acceptor character. Therefore the statement that low spin is attainable with strong field ligands is correct.

Statement (IV): “Aqueous solution of Mn(II) ions is yellow in colour.”

The aquated ion is [Mn(OH2)6]2+.[\text{Mn(OH}_2)_6]^{2+}. Because its d-d transitions are spin-forbidden (high-spin d5d^5), the complex is only very weakly coloured, appearing pale pink to colourless, not yellow. Statement (IV) is false.

We have now assessed each statement:

(I) True     (II) True     (III) True     (IV) False

So the correct set of statements is (I), (II) and (III) only.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Valence bond theory of complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicValence bond theory of complexes
TypeMultiple choice