JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — Valence bond theory of complexes
The correct order of spin-only magnetic moments among the following is: (Atomic number: Mn = 25, Co = 27, Ni = 28, Zn = 30)
SOLUTION
We have to compare the spin-only magnetic moments of the tetra-hedral complexes [MnCl4]2−,[CoCl4]2−,[NiCl4]2−,[ZnCl4]2−.
First, every chloride ion carries charge −1. Because four chloride ions are present, the total anionic charge supplied by the ligands is
4×(−1)=−4.
Each complex as a whole has charge −2. If we denote the oxidation state of the metal by x, we can write
x+(−4)=−2⟹x=+2.
So in every complex the central metal is in the +2 oxidation state, that is, Mn2+,Co2+,Ni2+,Zn2+.
Now we determine the number of d-electrons for each M2+ ion. The ground-state electronic configurations for the neutral atoms are
Mn : [Ar]3d54s2, Co : [Ar]3d74s2, Ni : [Ar]3d84s2, Zn : [Ar]3d104s2.
In forming the +2 ions, the two 4s electrons are lost first, so we get
Mn2+:3d5,
Co2+:3d7,
Ni2+:3d8,
Zn2+:3d10.
Chloride is a weak-field ligand and the complexes are tetra-hedral, so all four complexes are high-spin. Hence the number of unpaired electrons n equals that of the free high-spin ions:
nMn2+=5,
nCo2+=3,
nNi2+=2,
nZn2+=0.
The spin-only magnetic moment is given by the well-known formula
μ=n(n+2)BM,
where n is the number of unpaired electrons.
Substituting each value of n one by one, we obtain
For [MnCl4]2−:
μ=5(5+2)=35≈5.92BM.
For [CoCl4]2−:
μ=3(3+2)=15≈3.87BM.
For [NiCl4]2−:
μ=2(2+2)=8≈2.83BM.
For [ZnCl4]2−:
μ=0(0+2)=0BM.
The magnetic moments decrease in the sequence
[MnCl4]2−>[CoCl4]2−>[NiCl4]2−>[ZnCl4]2−.
Comparing with the given options, this order matches Option D.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Valence bond theory of complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.