RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — Valence bond theory of complexes

The correct combination is:

SOLUTION

First, we recall the ground-state electronic configuration of the free nickel atom. Nickel has atomic number 28, so in the isolated state

Ni:[Ar] 3d8 4s2.\text{Ni} : [\text{Ar}]\,3d^{8}\,4s^{2}.

When nickel forms complexes, the 4s electrons are lost first, and then, if necessary, 3d electrons are removed. The charge on the metal ion inside each complex therefore decides the d-electron count that must be used while discussing crystal-field splitting, hybridisation, geometry and magnetic behaviour.

We shall now analyse every complex appearing in the options one by one.

1. For [NiCl4]2−[\text{NiCl}_{4}]^{2-} we first work out the oxidation state of nickel.

Since each chloride carries a charge −1-1, the overall charge balance gives

x+4(−1)=−2⟹x=+2.x + 4(-1) = -2 \Longrightarrow x = +2.

Hence inside [NiCl4]2−[\text{NiCl}_{4}]^{2-} the metal centre is Ni2+\text{Ni}^{2+} and possesses

d8  configuration (because 28−2=26 and 26−18=8 electrons in the d subshell).d^{8}\; \text{configuration (because }28-2 = 26\text{ and }26-18 = 8\text{ electrons in the d subshell).}

Chloride (Cl−)\left(\text{Cl}^{-}\right) is a weak-field ligand. Crystal-field theory tells us that weak-field ligands produce a small splitting Δtet\Delta_{\text{tet}} in a tetrahedral environment, so electrons prefer to remain unpaired rather than pair up. For a d8d^{8} ion in a tetrahedral field the electronic distribution is

e  (↑↑)4  t2  (↑↑)4,e\;( \uparrow \uparrow )^{4}\;t_{2}\;( \uparrow \uparrow )^{4},

leaving

2  unpaired electrons.2\;\text{unpaired electrons}.

Because no pairing energy is paid, tetrahedral geometry is energetically favored over square-planar for weak-field ligands. Therefore

[NiCl4]2−[\text{NiCl}_{4}]^{2-} is tetrahedral and paramagnetic (2 unpaired e−e^{-}).

2. For [Ni(CN)4]2−[\text{Ni(CN)}_{4}]^{2-}, we again equate charges:

x+4(−1)=−2⟹x=+2,x + 4(-1) = -2 \Longrightarrow x = +2,

so the ion is also Ni2+(d8).\text{Ni}^{2+} (d^{8}). However, the ligand now is CN−,\text{CN}^{-}, a strong-field ligand according to the spectrochemical series. A strong-field ligand causes a large splitting Δsp\Delta_{\text{sp}} in a square-planar arrangement, large enough to make pairing of electrons cheaper than occupying the higher orbitals.

For a d8d^{8} ion in a square-planar field we use the energy order

dx2−y2>dxy>dz2>dxz,dyzd_{x^{2}-y^{2}} \gt d_{xy} \gt d_{z^{2}} \gt d_{xz}, d_{yz}

and fill electrons pairwise in the lower three levels, giving

dxz2 dyz2 dz22 dxy2 dx2−y20.d_{xz}^{2}\,d_{yz}^{2}\,d_{z^{2}}^{2}\,d_{xy}^{2}\, d_{x^{2}-y^{2}}^{0}.

This leaves

0  unpaired electrons,0\;\text{unpaired electrons},

so the complex is

square-planar and diamagnetic.\text{square-planar and diamagnetic.}

3. For [Ni(CO)4][\text{Ni(CO)}_{4}] we determine the oxidation state:

Carbonyl CO\text{CO} is a neutral ligand, the complex has no overall charge, so

x+4(0)=0⟹x=0.x + 4(0) = 0 \Longrightarrow x = 0.

The metal is therefore Ni0\text{Ni}^{0} with configuration

[Ar] 3d8 4s2.[\text{Ar}]\,3d^{8}\,4s^{2}.

Before complexation, both 4s electrons and the two 3d electrons occupying different orbitals shift so that all ten d electrons pair within the five 3d orbitals:

3d10,  4s0.3d^{10},\;4s^{0}.

Now the metal employs four equivalent sp3sp^{3} hybrid orbitals (originating from 4s and 4p) to accept lone-pair donation from four CO molecules. The d10d^{10} set remains intact and low in energy. Because CO is a very strong-field ligand, this arrangement leads to

tetrahedral geometry with 0 unpaired\text{tetrahedral geometry with 0 unpaired} electrons (diamagnetic).\text{electrons (diamagnetic).}

Having established the facts, we inspect the statements in each option:

Option A: [NiCl4]2−[\text{NiCl}_{4}]^{2-} is not square-planar and [Ni(CN)4]2−[\text{Ni(CN)}_{4}]^{2-} is not paramagnetic. Both parts are incorrect.

Option B: [Ni(CN)4]2−[\text{Ni(CN)}_{4}]^{2-} is not tetrahedral and [Ni(CO)4][\text{Ni(CO)}_{4}] is not paramagnetic. Both parts are wrong.

Option C: [NiCl4]2−[\text{NiCl}_{4}]^{2-} is indeed paramagnetic (2 unpaired electrons) and [Ni(CO)4][\text{Ni(CO)}_{4}] is indeed tetrahedral. Both statements are correct.

Option D: [NiCl4]2−[\text{NiCl}_{4}]^{2-} is not diamagnetic and [Ni(CO)4][\text{Ni(CO)}_{4}] is not square-planar. Both parts are incorrect.

Thus only Option C matches all the established electronic structures, geometries and magnetic behaviours. Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Valence bond theory of complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicValence bond theory of complexes
TypeMultiple choice